The processing speed of this article was relatively fast. The comments of the external review were returned in two months, and it was accepted in 5 months. It is best to cite more than two articles published in the journal if you (pretend to) submit to this journal. The complete review process is attached below: 2020-01-02, awaiting administrator’s processing; 2020-01-03, under review; 2020-03-06, evaluating recommendation; 2020-03-06, major revision; 2020-03-17, article received; 2020-03-18, under review; 2020-03-26, evaluating recommendation; 2020-03-26, major revision; 2020-03-26, article received; 2020-03-27, under review; 2020-05-30, minor revision; 2020-05-30, article received; 2020-06-01, under review; 2020-06-02, accept.

(15) Thank | chxifei

The manuscript was reviewed for about 2 months, and we waited another 2 months after the revision. During the period, there were 2 reviewers, one of whom asked quite sharp questions, and the other raised no big problem. After adding calculation examples and modifying the paper, it was still published. Thank you Dr LUCIA FARAVELLI!

(2) Thank | Eli

Submitted: 12-Aug-2019; Major Revision: 11-Nov-2019; Revision submitted: 05-Dec-2019; Accepted: 02-Jan-2020; First online published: 21-January-2020.

(3) Thank | Guang-Ming

Too slow, 8 months in the first review, reminded the editor, returned to the reviewer's opinion in the afternoon, and waited for two months after the minor revision. I then sent an email to ask about the situation and receive a reply one week later.

(0) Thank | peter

The second review was rejected, with one of the reviewers not letting go of the issue, making the entire submission process very lengthy.

(0) Thank | sdj

Hello, may I ask if the "under review" status of this journal means it is currently undergoing initial review, external review, or if the editor has not processed it at all?

(0) Thank | 机智的栗子

Could you please clarify whether the "under review" status of this journal means it is under initial review, external review, or if it has not been processed by the editor at all?

(0) Thank | 机智的栗子

The review comments are very professional, but the revision period is very long, so please submit your manuscript carefully.

(0) Thank | sdj

I have been waiting for over 2 months for my submission, it has been under review the whole time, and I have not received any response after sending multiple emails inquiring about the status.

(0) Thank | sdj

How long does it take for the first-instance opinion to be returned?

(0) Thank | 聪明的墨菲特

When I submitted it, it also showed "under review", it has been stuck for two months and there has been no progress.

(0) Thank | 聪明的墨菲特

Could you please clarify if the current status of this journal is only "under review" and that we are unable to see the specific progress?

(0) Thank | jkkkk12

Hello, how is the status of your recent journal articles?

(0) Thank | luojiabin_

Very slow, not recommended for submission

(0) Thank | MZH.sd

I think it was quite strict. In the first round of major revisions, three reviewers provided over 40 comments, and more than 10 were difficult to address. However, the suggestions made were very good, and the quality of the article was significantly improved. It took me three months to make the revisions. In the second round, two reviewers accepted the manuscript, but one requested major revisions. There were less than 10 comments, mostly focusing on methodological details. I added some additional literature review and conducted numerical simulations again, which took over a month. The manuscript was accepted the next day

(0) Thank | 张睿

Now Wiley and Hindawi are co-publishing, all open access

(0) Thank | tongtong111

Teacher, do you think your reviewing process is strict? Are the comments you provide objective and constructive?

(0) Thank | leo andesen

2023-05 submitted
2023-07 major revision (3 months for revision)
2023-10 submitted 1st-round revision
2023-11 major revision (3 months for revision)
2024-1 submitted 2nd-round revision
2024-1 accept

(0) Thank | 张睿

This journal is not just slow, the reviewers are fine, but any step stuck in the hands of the editors is at least a month. Starting from submission to publication can take up to 8 months, so be careful when submitting if graduating within a year

(0) Thank | xiao趴菜

Submission on March 17, 2023
First round of reviews returned on August 15, 2023
Uploaded first revised manuscript on August 19, 2023
Editor-in-chief reviewed on November 13, 2023 and provided comments
Uploaded second revised manuscript on November 17, 2023
Accepted on December 1, 2023

The journal is excellent, a top journal in the field of structural health monitoring.
After submitting in March, there was no editor assigned until May, and then it wasn't until August that the first round of reviews came back. Thankfully, there were minimal comments for revision, just minor edits. After the editor-in-chief handled it in November, they provided feedback that didn't align with the journal's focus, which scared me. I quickly revised the article and wrote a lengthy explanation of how it did fit the focus of the journal, which was the most nerve-wracking part. After that, the article was accepted and approved for publication. Overall, the submission process started slow but ended quickly. The first round of reviews was the most difficult to wait for, but it was rewarding, and the article was finally published without any major issues.
One thing I don't understand is that when I checked this journal on LetPub, it was listed as closed source with no open access, but when it came to payment, they claimed to be open access and required a $2300 publication fee. I don't understand, did they switch from closed source to open access? Will this affect the journal's ranking?

(0) Thank | nplxdsy

Why has it been half a month since I submitted the manuscript, but the editor has still not been assigned? Academic Editor Unassigned

(0) Thank | Daniel

Four months have passed and still unassigned

(0) Thank | hj

May I ask how long it takes for this journal to be published online after acceptance?

(0) Thank | sword1010

Is this journal now charging a fee for submissions? 2300 US dollars?

(0) Thank | Hongze Du

23-Oct-2021 SUBMITTED
31-Aug-2022 Reject
Under review for almost a year, this rubbish journal has ruined my youth. It almost caused me to delay graduation!!!

(0) Thank | kkkkk_________