After the article was rejected by Small and Materials Horizons one after another, due to anxious submission, I submitted my article to Nano Research on June 17; the first review comments were received on July 3. There were three reviewers, requiring a major revision: supplemented the data, did simulation analysis; although the overall evaluation was considerable, but the problem was sharp. I forgot which day to reply to the comments. August 3, the second review comments received. The first reviewer was still asking further questions. He was very serious and earnest, and felt that my analysis was still not credible (I am very speechless); on the morning of August 6, I replied to the second review opinion. I did not make additional experiments but responded to the reviewer's questions in a justified and well-grounded way; I was happy that on the evening of August 6, the editor sent us a notification email of acceptance. It was estimated that my response for the second review was reasonable and well-founded. Hope it can help everyone. There is also a question for you: after the notification is received, is there any process followed? When will it be assigned the DOI number or online? When will it be proofread? And approximately how long will it be published? Hope to get your reply, thank you!

(21) Thank | 2D materials

By 2020.04.14, real time impact factor: JMCA=11.590 rise: 0.80, CM=9.800 rise: −0.359, ACS Energy Letters=19.800 rise: 3.469, CEJ=10.810 rise: 2.455, Nano Research=8.330 rise: −0.815 ACS AMI=8.990 rise: 0.534, JPS=8.430 rise: 0.963, JEC=7.180 rise: 2.018, JMST=6.050 rise: 1.010, EA=6.330 rise: 0.947, Nanoscale=7.070 rise: 0.100, CC=6.150 rise: −0.014, JPCC=4.260 rise: −0.049, Applied Surface Science=6.280 rise: 1.125

(15) Thank | 匿名0

By December 22, 2019, real-time impact factor: nano research=7.81, CC=5.73, Chemical Science=8.88, ACS central science=11.69, JACS=13.7, nanoscale=6.13, JEC=6.8, JMCA=10.8, CEJ=10.44, EA=6.05, AMI=8.41, JPS=7.9, materials horizons=11.63, advanced science=14.82 energy storage materials=15.86, ACS energy letters=17.64, AEM=23.51, materials today energy=5.43

(2) Thank | penguin

The carbon nanotubes I made were nano-directional, but not as hot as graphene. But my article is still innovative. It required an overhaul based on the comments of three reviewers. The review speed is fast. The submission instructions were written within 4 weeks.

(2) Thank | Anonymous

Hello, may I ask where to add the author when submitting a manuscript? Why can I only add one corresponding author on my end and not able to add others?

(0) Thank | xxxzhong

The review process is quite fast.
2025-02-07 Submitted
2025-02-09 Under Review
2025-02-28 Major Revision
2025-03-07 Resubmitted
2023-03-20 Accepted

(0) Thank | klxdzh

Submission on 28th November 2024
Minor revisions on 6th January 2025
Feedback on 13th January 2025
Acceptance on 16th January 2025
Thanks to editor Xun Wang.

(0) Thank | Captain Pirate

Received on 12.31, wishing the journal continued success.

(0) Thank | Yuuki233

Submission on October 15, 2024
Major revision on November 7
Returned on November 30
Waiting for editorial decision on December 30

(0) Thank | Yuuki233

It has been 53 days since my first trial and there has been no movement yet.

(0) Thank | 我是上帝的宠儿

How long is the review period for everyone? The official website says the review will be completed within two weeks, why is there still no progress after a month?

(0) Thank | Captain Pirate

Now it is open source and free of charge.

(0) Thank | Yuuki233

May I ask if Nano Research charges a fee?

(0) Thank | lorna639

I have been back for 15 days.

(0) Thank | Yuuki233

I won't dare to invest in the future anyway. My classmates in their group can make profits from scratch in just one month.

(0) Thank | 95277

How long have you been back?

(0) Thank | 95277

I have submitted my revised manuscript for the second round of review. Does this journal not have a deadline for reviewing submissions?

(0) Thank | Yuuki233

It has been 42 days since the second trial.

(0) Thank | 95277

How did your results turn out?

(0) Thank | 我是上帝的宠儿

December 5th, 2024 is Awaiting Decision.

(0) Thank | 塞外几年

The first review gave a small repair 50 days, and the second review has been 30 days. Are we saying that it is so slow if we are not a relative? What should we do in the future?

(0) Thank | 95277

I also recorded it.
18-11-2024, submitted
19-11-2024, under review
Hope for a good outcome.

(0) Thank | 塞外几年

Excuse me, does the journal require the provision of raw data?

(0) Thank | Avery-Yang

May I ask if it is still UR right now?

(0) Thank | 荆棘QAQ

Should Under Review come first or With Editor? I submitted it yesterday and it is already Under Review today.

(0) Thank | 塞外几年