The manuscript was submitted on November 11 2019. I sent an email to inquire the editor about the status of review on December 25 2019, which was Christmas Day. The rejection mail was received on January 3 2020. The comments of two reviewers were major revision and rejection. The comments of the reviewer who required major revision were pertinent, and the comments on the manuscript raised were detailed, which was helpful and enlightening to me. The reviewer who rejected the manuscript said two or three official language, and I felt that he didn’t read the manuscript carefully. It was quite quick for the return of review comments in two months after the submission to the SCI journals, but (status of the article in the) system of this journal was not updated in time. I thought that no reviewer was assigned when I urged it, because the system showed that there was no editor assigned. In short, it is hopeful to be accepted by the Q4 SCI journal. It is a pity. I will work harder in the future!

(6) Thank | mayiintianda

One of my manuscript was accepted. Two reviewers, one requested a minor revision and the other one a major revision. After the revision, paper was accepted by the reviewer who requested minor revision, and it was rejected by the other reviewer who requested major revision. Fortunately, the editor gave the opportunity to revise again, and was accepted after revision. It has been online for 2 months and it has not been published yet. I don't know when it can be retrieved? The paper of the buddy above has been online for 5 months and has not been published yet...

(7) Thank | feicai88

I had a paper just got accepted. Two reviewers, one reviewer is more professional, and recommended a minor revision; the other reviewer is not professional enough, requiring a major revision. After the revision, one agreed to accept the paper, and the other recommended a rejection. The reason for rejection was obviously contradictory to the conclusion of the first review. It felt like it’s another reviewer for this time, and it was extremely unprofessional. Fortunately, the editor decided to accept. It has been online for 5 months and it has not been published yet. After online, I received 2 invitations to review for the journal.

(8) Thank | delta

One directly gave a rejection. One gave a major review for a major revision. But the editor refused to accept it. The reviewers’ comments were very pertinent. The review was critical of my English, as it is my second language.

(0) Thank | 冷

Hired, the subsequent processing speed is still very fast.

(0) Thank | 稳少

Hello, I would like to ask if there are any restrictions on the word count and page count for this journal. Is it correct that the author guidelines show a limit of 7000 characters?

(0) Thank | gh1

After the emerald submission is authorized, how many days will it take to receive the proof? Will only the corresponding author receive an email? Can the co-authors also receive it?

(0) Thank | smile_yy

There has been an update, my CE and EIC have been changed to new editors, and they have given me minor revisions. I believe they will soon start processing everyone's submissions.

(0) Thank | 稳少

Still waiting for the office to handle it? How long do we have to wait? It's been 25 days already, really urgent. Does anyone know when the editor can start processing it?

(0) Thank | 张若彬

Has anyone heard any news? I checked the official website and there is still no new editor-in-chief appointed. How long do we have to wait?

(0) Thank | kkyyxx

The editorial team has undergone changes, with the new editor-in-chief just taking office, so there will be a delay for some time.

(0) Thank | 稳少

Upstairs wpi99, I also sent an email yesterday and have not received a reply yet... This journal is getting slower and slower.

(0) Thank | kkyyxx

Upstairs kkyyxx, I have been submitting for two months, but it is still in the "Awaiting EO Checklist" status. I have sent emails but have not received any response.

(0) Thank | wpie99

It has been three months since I submitted my article, and I am still waiting for the score. I am considering whether to send an email to follow up. May I ask how long it took for you to receive feedback on your submission?

(0) Thank | kkyyxx

Has anyone heard any news recently about submissions, revisions, or acceptances? It's been almost 2 months since I submitted my revisions and I haven't heard anything yet. It has been stuck at "awaiting reviewer scores" for a while.

(0) Thank | 稳少

Waiting for EO Checklist, it has been in this state for many days.

(0) Thank | wpie99

Original poster, what's the progress? I also submitted an article, after Christmas, and am currently waiting for the editorial office to process it.

(0) Thank | wpie99

Please record the information that has been submitted, hoping for a prompt response.

(0) Thank | 唯一02

"awaiting reviewer scores" means waiting for the scores from reviewers. Does "awaiting reviewer selection" mean preparing for review on the day I submitted it?

(0) Thank | kkyyxx

My submission also became in the "waiting for reviewer selection" status on the same day I submitted it. Does this mean it is ready for review? Have you found out yet?

(0) Thank | kkyyxx

Congratulations! ? May I ask if this journal has a submission template available?

(0) Thank | 张张！

The submission was rejected on the same day it was submitted, very quickly.

(1) Thank | xuneu

2024.3 提交
2024.6 修订
2024.7 接受

(0) Thank | OverflowChu

Can the boss share the template of this journal? Thank you!!! sunyu991211@163.com

(0) Thank | 小么哥

Boss, can you send me the template for this issue of the journal? Thank you so much! sunyu991211@163.com

(0) Thank | 小么哥