It is the last update for the submission, and all efforts are not wasted. Congratulations upstairs! 2020.8.15, submitted in the morning; 2020.8.19, the status was awaiting admin checklist; 2020.8.21, the status changed to awaiting EIC immediate decision, under review in the morning; 2020.8.22, the status changed to waiting EIC immediate decision, awaiting reviewer assignment in the morning; 2020.8.25, the status updated in the morning, awaiting EIC immediate decision, awaiting reviewer scores; 2020.8.26, the status updated in the morning, awaiting EIC immediate decision, awaiting AE assignment; 2020.8.26, the review comments were received in the evening, and major revision was required; 2020.9.15, the review comments were returned in the evening; 2020.9.16, the revised manuscript was sent back to the original reviewers in the morning; 2020.10.2, the comments of the second review were received in the evening; 2020.10.9, the revised manuscript was returned at noon, and it was accepted that night.

(7) Thank | nature-publisher

Same as upstairs. I will continue to update and hope it can bring good luck! The review speed of nature-publisher is so fast that I was shocked. Good luck to both of us! 2020.8.15, submitted in the morning; 2020.8.19, the status was awaiting admin checklist; 2020.8.21 the status changed to waiting EIC immediate decision, under review in the morning; 2020.8.22, the status changed to waiting EIC immediate decision, awaiting reviewer assignment in the morning.; 2020.8.25, the status was updated in the morning: awaiting EIC immediate decision, awaiting reviewer scores; 2020.9.17, the status was updated in the morning: awaiting EIC immediate decision, awaiting AE assignment; 2020.9.21, the status was updated in the morning: awaiting EIC immediate decision, awaiting AE recommendation.

(0) Thank | Lynnsai

May the progress update bring me good luck! 2020.8.15, in the morning, submitted; 2020.8.19 status changed to awaiting admin checklist; 2020.8.21, in the morning, status became awaiting EIC immediate decision, under review; 2020.8.22, in the morning, status became waiting EIC immediate decision, awaiting reviewer assignment; 2020.8.25, in the morning, status became awaiting EIC immediate decision, awaiting reviewer scores; 2020.8.26, in the morning, status became awaiting EIC immediate decision, awaiting ae assignment; 2020.8.26 in the evening, review comments received, requiring a major revision. 2020.9.15, in the evening, review comments received; 2020.9.16, in the morning, status became awaiting EIC immediate decision, awaiting reviewer scores.

(101) Thank | nature-publisher

Recently, I submitted the full text of traditional ceramic research. In the comments, there was one suggestion to accept, one suggestion to overhaul, and the deputy editor also gave more than a dozen very professional and useful opinions. After completing the revisions, I spent nearly two months supplementing the data. My paper was accepted one week after submitting the changes.

(1) Thank | 淡然处之

The new version of the system only has "Under review" status, and updates will generally be made about once a month.

(1) Thank | zhouxiaoyucoco

Hello, what does it mean when there is only one status "under review" after submission?

(1) Thank | 清茫

2024.4.8 Submission
2024.6.9 Major revision, additional calculations
2024.7.11 Re-submission
2024.7.31 Minor revision
2024.8.7 Re-submission
2024.8.14 Acceptance

(0) Thank | 水工

Should the picture be placed at the end, with the text separately, or should only the text be included, with the pictures uploaded one by one? Could you please add me on WeChat to chat in more detail? I have been rejected twice already.

(1) Thank | moluo

Reviewer is very professional and an expert in the field, they provided many suggestions, no need to add additional experiments.

(0) Thank | Clearlove

5.19 submission format issues, returned
5.29 resubmitted
6.2 under review, awaiting editor decision
6.5 awaiting reviewer assignment changed to awaiting reviewer scores
7.7 awaiting AE assignment changed to awaiting AE assessment
7.16 EIC decision changed to major revision in the afternoon
2 reviewers plus AE

(0) Thank | Clearlove

He asked me to remove the picture, so you just need to make the changes he mentioned.

(1) Thank | zhouxiaoyucoco

Hello, I also had a Word document that was not converted to PDF and was sent back on the 7th of November. How did you end up resolving it?

(1) Thank | moluo

The status remains Awaiting EIC Immediate Decision. It has been under review for three weeks. Has it not been sent for approval yet?

(1) Thank | yhou1004

Alumni NJ Tech, may I ask how long it takes to review?

(1) Thank | zhouxiaoyucoco

The first attempt at Mei Tao, it is said that the reviewers are very professional and the journal has a high degree of recognition, so let's give it a try.
2024.7.5 Submitted
2024.7.9 Under Review Thank Mei Tao for the quick review
2024.7.11 Returned for formatting issues X1
2024.7.11 Submitted
2024.7.13 Under Review
2024.7.18 Returned for formatting issues X2
2024.7.18 Submitted
2024.7.19 Under review
2024.8.25 Rejected (2 reviewers, 1 reject, 1 minor revision)
2024.8.27 Appeal
2024.9.1 Editor's reply, agreeing to reconsider
2024.9.3 Editor notified that decision has been changed to Rescinded
2024.9.4 In Revision (Revision 1)
2024.9.9 Submitted (Revision 1)
2024.9.10 Under Review
2024.9.12 Returned for image formatting issues
2024.9.13 Submitted
2024.10.9 Accept

(1) Thank | zhouxiaoyucoco

Hello, I also have the same issue. May I ask how you resolved it?

(1) Thank | 小白白

I want to ask everyone, what are the format requirements for manuscripts when submitting? About 2 weeks after submission, the editorial department sent an email saying there were issues with the manuscript. The email read: "because the manuscript was not properly converted and the proof only contains the cover page. Each listed item must be addressed and modified in the manuscript. Can anyone tell me what went wrong?"

(0) Thank | 接accept!

I would like to ask everyone, what is the status of "under consideration"? The first submission had formatting issues, so the editor asked for a revision before resubmission. After the second submission, it still shows "under consideration." I searched on Baidu and some people said it means the reviewer is looking for a suitable editor, while others said it means the editor is considering whether to submit it for review

(2) Thank | Maddy

09.06 Submission
09.13 Returned, resubmitted
12.09 First round of reviews came back, one reviewer provided a lot of comments, one reviewer had no comments and suggested acceptance.
12.24 Returned
1.13 Re-reviewed, Reviewer 1 provided 2 more comments but suggested acceptance. Returned the same day.
Still Awaiting Admin Checklist till now.
The reviewers are very knowledgeable and raised many professional questions. The only downside is that it took a long time to find reviewers and the speed of editorial processing is average. However, I am grateful for the editors' and reviewers' affirmation of my work. Americeramics as an established journal has a good reputation, but I do not recommend impatient colleagues to submit articles

(1) Thank | hoda

Reading other people's comments, the review usually takes about a month to get the results. Just be patient and wait a little longer

(0) Thank | qq77qq

My status is awaiting EIC immediate decision and awaiting reviewer scores, it has been a week now and I don't know when I will get the results. It's really slow, I started submitting on September 6th

(0) Thank | hoda

Today should be submission day

(0) Thank | qq77qq

Hey, how are you feeling now?

(0) Thank | 那搁浅的梦

10.8 submission
12.5 major revisions requested, but only 7 comments and no additional experiments required
12.7 resubmitted after revisions
12.30 accepted
Thank you to the editor Yiquan Wu and the kind-hearted reviewers. The only downside is that the impact factor has decreased this year. It is somewhat frustrating to see a long-established journal like Meitao being treated in such a way by the Chinese Academy of Sciences

(5) Thank | NJTECHxxj

It feels like playing around, just fooling around

(0) Thank | 于亚杰