Hello, may I ask how long it usually takes to enter "under review"?

(0) Thank | 我不是AI

2025.02.12 with editor

(0) Thank | 我不是AI

After submitting, the manuscript remained in a "with editor" status. One month later, I emailed the chief editor to inquire about the status, only to receive an immediate rejection without any explanation.

(0) Thank | rpcheng

2024.10.29 Submitted With Editor
2024.11.21 Still With Editor
.....It's really slow, no response at all

(0) Thank | Asan

Still under review, the speed is really slow.

(0) Thank | 立白

It's been 4 months since I submitted it, and it's still with the editor. I followed up once at the three-month mark. I'm feeling frustrated as I'm waiting for this graduation piece.

(1) Thank | JackJack

It has been under review after 5 days of submission and there is still no result after two weeks.

(0) Thank | 立白

Have you received it? How many reviewers are usually involved in the review process?

(0) Thank | 快给我accepted

May 23, 23 - under review
November 23, 23 - still under review
Looking at the status, invited over a dozen reviewers, but only one accepted the review
Ah ah ah, what's going on, why is it so slow?

(0) Thank | 快给我accepted

Does anyone know how long the second review process for this journal takes?

(0) Thank | Walkerwang

At the beginning, no one accepted the manuscript for review. Later, the editor kept increasing the number of invitations, ultimately reaching 28. Currently, three people have accepted the manuscript for review.

(0) Thank | Walkerwang

Hey, classmate, has your situation changed? Are you still waiting for the reviewer? I have been waiting for four or five months and still have only one reviewer.

(0) Thank | 吃糖

This journal is so slow, it's been almost five months and still no news.

(0) Thank | 如痴如醉

The link he provided can only show the current status of the manuscript, such as "under review," but cannot show the names of the reviewers.

(0) Thank | Walkerwang

Elsevier journals all have manuscript status tracking services. They will send you a link where you can see how many reviewers have reviewed your manuscript.

(0) Thank | 如痴如醉

How do I know if it has been accepted by several reviewers?

(0) Thank | Walkerwang

2022. At the end of November, only one reviewer has agreed to review.

(0) Thank | 919

Received at Editorial Office: 23 Mar 2022
Article revised: 22 May 2022, Revised version submitted on June 6th
Article revised: 9 Aug 2022, Revised version submitted on August 17th
Article accepted for publication: 24 Aug 2022

(0) Thank | honor4cn

Let's talk about the timeline of the paper. We submitted our paper to the CCF B conference and it was accepted at that time. However, there were still many contents that could be added later. The journal added about 50% new content, and the paper expanded from 15 pages to 45 pages.

Submitted on July 5th, 2021,
Received major revisions in November 2021, returned for revisions at the end of November;
Received minor revisions on April 22nd, 2022, returned for revisions at the end of April;
Accepted on July 7th, 2022.

In summary, it took one year for the paper to be accepted.

(0) Thank | superLiu

Submit in January, make revisions in April, submit again after completing revisions in May, acceptance by the end of June, approximately a total of 5 months, with about 3 months of back-and-forth with reviewers. The journal is very good and worth submitting to!

(0) Thank | 梦不到的刀塔

May I ask what is the conference expansion referring to?

(0) Thank | 猫三狗四

One article conference expansion
Submitted in July 2021
Received major revisions in early November 2021
Returned for revisions at the end of November 2021
Received minor revisions on April 22, 2022, currently undergoing minor revisions.

(0) Thank | superLiu

What is the main reason for such a long time? Has it been rushed?

(0) Thank | aaronbf

Submission in March
Major revisions in August, applied for an extension to make modifications
Re-submitted in November
Received acceptance notification in January

The reviewer's comments were very professional and fair, after all, it is a well-established journal in the field of distributed systems!

(1) Thank | Thorin006

Submitted in February, received major revision comments in October, submitted minor revisions one month later, received minor revision comments in mid-December, accepted in January of the following year after making changes.

(1) Thank | avicialain