The speed is moderate. The reviewers’ comments are many and detailed, difficult to answer, but they have greatly helped improve the article. The editor Xia is very nice and fast. 2020.3.22 Submitted to Journal; 2020.3.22 With Editor; 2020.3.26 Under Review; 2020.4.23 Under Editor Evaluation; 2020.4.27 Major Revisions; 2020.5.21 Revision Submitted to Journal; 2020.5.21 Under Review; 2020.6.11 Required Reviews Completed; 2020.6.12 Minor Revisions; 2020.6.16 Revision Submitted to Journal; 2020.6.18 Accept.

(13) Thank | 独奏狮子

The editor Mr. Xia sent my manuscript for review very quickly, basically within a week. My first SCI paper. It took too long for the reviewers to review the manuscript! On May 22th, I submitted it. On May 22th, I received the recommendation of major revisions, asking for revision within two months. I supplemented the experiments for more than a month. On October 24th, I returned the revised manuscript. On December 7th, I received the recommendation of minor revisions. On December 8th, I returned the revised manuscript. On December 9th, it was accepted. Friendship reminds: please be careful if you can’t wait!!!

(1) Thank | 是琪不是琦呀

January 17, 2019, with editor. January 21, 2019, under review. February 28, major revision. April 25, revised manuscript submitted. May 10, required reviews completed. May 14, accepted. Generally speaking, the journal is still very efficient. The first review was more than one month and it took me two months to make the major revision. It was under review after resubmission, then required reviews completed after half a month, and accepted four days later. Thanks to the journal’s editor: Juan M. Feliu.

(0) Thank | superchen999

Very smooth submission experience. Very serious and helpful reviews.

(2) Thank | 1041699490@qq.com

Which editor is it? So efficient.

(0) Thank | zzz111

The external audit opinion came back a month later on February 13th.

(0) Thank | 投都大了

How are things going now?

(0) Thank | SCIxiaoba

2.2 Submitted to Journal

(0) Thank | Dannie爱喝绿豆泥

Jan-10, submit to journal
Jan-20, still submit to journal...

(0) Thank | 投都大了

2024.7.12 Submitted
2024.7.12 With editor
2024.7.12 Under review
2024.7.29 Returned for major revisions
2024.8.13 Revisions completed and resubmitted
2024.8.14 With editor
2024.8.14 Under review
2024.8.15 Review completed
2024.8.16 Returned for major revisions
2024.8.25 Resubmitted after second round of major revisions
2024.8.27 With editor
2024.8.27 Under review (review completed the same day)
2024.8.29 Accepted

(0) Thank | 柯不海

The second review draft has been completed, but it has been 10 days and the results have not yet been released.

(0) Thank | 莫莫

I transferred from EA. Came back in just one month, Xiao Xiu. Then accepted in one month, published very quickly

(1) Thank | 加油啊（飞升）

Friend, what was the outcome in the end?

(1) Thank | 材料学子0827

Why are there only 5 comments when directly searching for the Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry on letpub? Many comment information cannot be seen. Only after finding the previous link can more comments be seen.

(0) Thank | Zebra

2022.7.25 Major revision 

2022.7.25 denotes the date of a major revision.

(1) Thank | 材料学子0827

Overall, the submission process was fast. The first review took 17 days, and the second review took less than 7 days. Each time, the submission was with the editor on the same day and under review the next day. The first review required major revisions, with two reviewers raising a total of 13 questions. Some questions were difficult to answer, and additional experiments were requested, which took 20 days to complete. In general, the reviewers were fair and the editor was efficient. However, I spent more than ten days working on the major revisions, with a ten-day gap in between where no work was done. If there could be some improvement in the speed, it would be even faster. Finally, I would like to thank the reviewers for their accurate feedback, as well as Professor Xia from Nanjing University and Professor Marcin Opallo from Poland.

(91) Thank | 材料学子0827

2022.7.4 Submit to the journal
2022.7.5 With editor
2022.7.7 Under review
2022.7.24 Required reviews completed
2022.8.12 Revision submitted to journal
2022.8.13 With editor
2022.8.14 Under review
2022.8.20 Required reviews completed
2022.8.20 Completed - Accept

(1) Thank | 材料学子0827

After replying, will it be directly accepted? Is there a review process?

(1) Thank | 材料学子0827

May 06, 2022 Submission to journal
May 12, 2022 With Editor
May 14, 2022 Under Review
Jun 07, 2022 Required Reviews Completed
Jun 29, 2022 Major revision
Jul 10, 2022 Revision Submitted to Journal
Jul 12, 2022 With Editor
Jul 18, 2022 Under Review
Aug 03, 2022 Accept

Approximately three months or so, with one major revision in between. Thank you to the editor and two reviewers!

(2) Thank | 是瓜皮瑞瑞呀

External audit will take about a month.

(0) Thank | 生命不息 科研不止

Hello, may I ask if it is necessary for all authors to click on the link to confirm before submitting to the journal? Why did it take two days to submit to the journal and yet we still kept receiving email reminders for each author to confirm?

(0) Thank | ZhouEtin

Hello, may I ask if all authors must click on the link to confirm before submitting to the journal? Why did it take two days to submit to the journal and yet the email reminders for authors to confirm continued?

(0) Thank | ZhouEtin

Why did it take two days to submit to the journal and why are you constantly sending emails to remind each author to confirm? Is it necessary for all authors to click on the link and confirm before submitting to the journal?

(0) Thank | ZhouEtin

How long did you use for the external audit? How many times did the Under Review time change?

(0) Thank | 双一流冲一波

First time selecting and submitting, I was very fortunate to be accepted. The journal is very reputable and the editorial staff is very friendly. Additionally, both reviewers are very professional in the field of electrocatalysis, with a focus on theoretical and mechanistic research. After major revisions, I finally received good news. However, the journal's review process is not very fast, and I hope that it will continue to improve!

(4) Thank | 生命不息 科研不止