This time-honored SCI journal of ASME, has a good reputation in the industry. I have submitted two manuscripts. I personally feel that the reviewers’ opinions are very pertinent and professional, and the review speed is also good. The results are generally given within 3 months. Of course, I wrote and submitted the manuscript according to the Latex template provided by ASME. I personally feel that if the submission format does not meet the requirements, it may cause problems such as long review time. It is recommended to format the manuscript according to the journal's requirements.

(7) Thank | M

It was submitted at the beginning of April 2018 and rejected at the end of November 2018. I personally feel that the review comments were quite pertinent, but the review speed was really too slow. Those who have time requirements for articles must think twice about this journal.

(2) Thank | 轩尼诗人

Very helpful reviews. About 3 months to first decision. Overall a very good journal.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

I would like to ask, is it required for the pictures to be in color when publishing?

(0) Thank | !!!135

The journal is a well-established one, with very good reviews for submitted papers. However, the speed is relatively slow, taking a year and a half from submission to acceptance, and requiring three revisions before acceptance

(0) Thank | wuyun123

The first trial has not been concluded in 8 months.

(0) Thank | frank.l.mi

Oct 4, 2022---Still under review until now.
It's been too slow, almost half a year has passed and there has been no response from the first review. I sent a reminder email in February, but no one responded for over a month. I'm frustrated with this journal, I don't want to submit my work to it anymore.

(0) Thank | frank.l.mi

The first trial and the second trial are both around three months.

(0) Thank | paperKing6688

Hello, may I ask how long it usually takes for your article submission to receive the first review comments?

(0) Thank | Augerstern

The reviewers are very careful, and the paper is accepted after minor revisions. As a well-established control journal under ASME, it is highly recognized in the industry. However, it may not have caught up with the AI trend, so the impact factor has decreased significantly. Overall, it is still very good in terms of control applications.

(2) Thank | paperKing6688

2013.10.17--PaperSubmit2013.10.25--Associate Editor assigned2013.10.31--Paper under review

(0) Thank | Anonymous

2012.02.28Submission, 2012.11.11 review finished, 2013.01.24 gives review comments, two reviewers, overhaul, feelings are more pertinent; 2013.01.30 revisited, 2013.04.01 gives the review comments, or two people, but feels that there is a reviewer changed, the reviewer has no opinion, the deputy editor requested minor repairs, mainly to clarify and refine the innovation of the article, 2013.04.09Back, 2013.06.06 review finished, 2013.06.20 acceptd, from submission to the final employment lasted 16 months, relatively slow, but personally feel that the journal is more formal, rigorous attitude, SCI veteran journal, you can check the status of submission at any time.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Journal Homepage URL: http://asmedl.aip.org.ezaccess.libraries.psu.edu/DynamicSys/

(0) Thank | Anonymous