Top journal in aerospace. The review is slow, the expert review is very professional. Rejected for language issues on the first submission.

(6) Thank | Anonymous

2025-01-20~Present: Awaiting EIC Checklist status remains unchanged.

(0) Thank | 吴提

Awaiting Author Confirmation Forms Completion
Author Confirmation Form Completion submitted
(07-Oct-2024) - view

This status has been pending for many days, does anyone know what the situation is? All author emails have been confirmed.

(0) Thank | unbrellalll

The speed is too slow. It's been over ten days and it's still Awaiting EIC Checklist. I'm speechless.

(3) Thank | Zheng_W_L

It's been two months, and it has always been "Awaiting Associate Editor Assignment". It has not been sent for review yet. I am considering withdrawing the submission.

(0) Thank | 酸菜馅饺子

Submitted for 5 months, always awaiting editor assignment, finally had to withdraw the submission. Truly speechless.

(0) Thank | hyshao

It's been almost three months, and they are still assigning AE. They don't even send it for external review. If the quality of the article is not good enough, you can just return it to me. What's the point of leaving it hanging like this?

(1) Thank | 哈哈酱

Brother, how many reviewers are there?

(0) Thank | acta7

First review: 6 months for minor revisions
Second review: 3 months for acceptance
I don't understand why such a prestigious journal like this has such low popularity, not only in terms of impact factor, but even the discussions on letpub are scarce. Look at how lively the discussions are in the adjacent aerospace journal

(2) Thank | hntter

Personally, I feel that JA is slightly better than AST. Some of AST's articles are very good, but some have a lower quality, while JA is more consistently average

(0) Thank | hntter

How is this journal? Compared to Aerospace Science and Technology, which one has a higher recognition? Which one is more difficult?

(0) Thank | AHH

is not a top journal, an entry journal.Progress in aero science is the top

(1) Thank | Anonymous

Introduction to the aviation field, relatively speaking, the quality is not bad, the amount of articles is large every year, but the volume of receiving is also large, the speed is also faster, more than oneMonthly review time,

(0) Thank | Anonymous