After the status changed to waiting EIC decision, it then changed to under review. However, the result of the review was returned soon. Now, it changed in to waiting EIC decision again. I continue to look forward to a good result.

(1) Thank | 彬彬

One month after the first submission to this journal, the review comments returned, with one major revision, one acceptance, and one rejection. Finally, the editor-in-chief rejected it and said welcome to submit again. After holding it in his hand for a month, we supplemented the data and revised the manuscript and submitted it again. I don’t know what will happen. Now it’s Under review. I’m looking forward to a good luck. For new year’s sake, please show me an acceptance~

(4) Thank | paper-AbAo

I saw it was still under review yesterday, and today’s review is directly Awaiting EIC Decision. Did the review comments of this journal directly return to the editor? Checking at the previous submission experience, it said that even if it was returned, there was still a long time period for the revision. Good luck!

(0) Thank | 筱团

Only 11 days for review. 4 reviewers. Numerous comments.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Submitted at the end of October in 24th year. Under review in November. Received reviewer comments in February of 25th year, with two minor revisions. Accepted on March 24th. The editorial process was very efficient, but the extended timeline may be due to the niche nature of the topic, making it difficult to find suitable reviewers.

(0) Thank | zstarry

Why didn't I find the segmentation of the Chinese Academy of Sciences for 2025?

(0) Thank | 用W代替L的小工科生

May I ask how long it takes for the publication information to be released after acceptance by this journal? It has been 11 days for me and I have not received any updates yet.

(0) Thank | xzzhdw

May I ask how long it takes for the publication information to be given after acceptance by the journal? It has been over 10 days for me and I have not received any updates.

(0) Thank | xzzhdw

Submission deadline for October 18.
Currently under peer review.

(0) Thank | haozi1

Can I ask how long it takes for your review process? I have been waiting for a week for my submission to be reviewed by the editors.

(0) Thank | 小许许

Just submitted today, with editor.

(0) Thank | 小许许

The reviewer is fast, but it has been three months and the review is still ongoing.

(0) Thank | R_hhh

7.18 Hiring

(0) Thank | 明同学

First experience of being reviewed four times.

(0) Thank | 明同学

7.16 Three revisions
7.17 Three revisions revised
7.18 peer review

(0) Thank | 明同学

Revised on 6.24
Submitted for external review again, it's been reviewed three times, a bit difficult to pass.

(0) Thank | 明同学

6.15 Added two more reviewers, it's difficult to handle. The original reviewer dropped out, reviewer two accepted, reviewer three suggested major revisions, and reviewer four suggested minor revisions

(0) Thank | 明同学

5.8 submission
5.13 revisions
5.26 resubmission
Waiting for response

(0) Thank | 明同学

3.1 Submission
4.27 Major Revision
5.7 Revision
5.27 Minor Revision
5.30 Revision
6.4 Acceptance
The fourth district is also a white moonlight

(0) Thank | 明同学

2024.02.18 Submission
2024.03.25 Review comments returned, one reject, one minor revision, one major revision
2024.04.09 Resubmission for revision
2024.04.29 Acceptance
Overall, the submission process was relatively smooth, and the reviewers' comments were quite constructive. Hope the journal continues to improve!

(0) Thank | huangmin#123

14 Apr, 2024 submission accepted
Thank you Werner Weppner for the quick processing, accepted after three days of revision

(0) Thank | 科研小白2.0

Can I still join the one that is already being reviewed? I didn't know about this service

(0) Thank | aniu

When submitting a manuscript, authors have the option to include the in Review service provided by Springer Nature, where they can view more detailed submission status

(0) Thank | 科研小白2.0

Where did you see these detailed information? I am just communication, but I can only see the submissions, I didn't see any reviewers accepting the invitations

(0) Thank | aniu

Submission Experience:
06 Mar 2024: First submitted to journal
08 Mar 2024: Editor assigned by journal
08 Mar 2024: Submission checks completed at journal
14 Mar 2024: Reviewers invited by journal
16 Mar 2024: Reviewers agreed at journal
27 Mar 2024: Reviews received at journal
06 Apr 2024: Editorial decision - revision requested
11 Apr 2024: Revision received
12 Apr 2024: Submission under peer review

审稿速度还是挺快的，一个月内就给了初稿的决定，给了14天修改时间。目前处于返修审稿阶段，希望能有好的结果

(0) Thank | 进無止境