The work content is theoretical derivation and numerical verification; the purpose is to unify the existing observation results in the literature and predict the influence of related parameters. The timeline is as following: 20191116 first submission; 20200327 Revision requested; 20200411 Submit revised manuscript; 20200411 Accepted. First review took more than three months. It was accepted the day of uploading the manuscript. The speed was amazing.

(1) Thank | 梦泽

10 days after submission, it was “with editor (editor-in-chief)”. After the change of associate editor, K. Mahesh, it was with editor again. 10 days later, I was suggested submitting to the application engineering journals. Obviously, the associate editor has published several similar articles in it. Heart tired.

(5) Thank | lu1563

Revisions were recommended 37 days after submitting the manuscript. It was directly accepted 16 days after revised submission. It was online the next day. It lasted a total of 67 days. I personally thought that the speed of synthesis was acceptable. The reviewers had high requirements for innovation and meaning, but moderate requirements for language. The speed of the editor was satisfying.

(3) Thank | 进击吧JOJO

Journal has gotten much faster. Overall quality is good.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

2024.11.29 submitted to journal
2024.12.04 with editor
2024.12.10 Under Review by Reviewer 1
2024.12.16 Under Review by Reviewer 2
2025.01.17 Required Reviews Complete
2025.02.15 Revised Submission
2025.03.17 Required Reviews Complete
2025.03.29 accepted

(0) Thank | Kevin K

Watch out for lightning. The editing efficiency is extremely low.

(0) Thank | lm1027

Submit to journal on August 6th. It has been almost a month and still with editor.

(0) Thank | lm1027

What do you think of this journal? It has always been in the second district and is not in the top list of the Chinese Academy of Sciences.

(0) Thank | fwjkbce

Direct hire within 20 days.

(0) Thank | zhuifeng1621

May I ask if it is possible to see a few reviewers accepting manuscripts on the Elsevier public account for this journal?

(0) Thank | TINGS

Submitted to journal on 5.22 and still pending as of 6.1

(0) Thank | litiken

2024-1-24: submitted
2024-2-22: First review: 1. yes. 2. Major revision or rejection. 3. Acceptable with minor revisions. 4. Acceptable with minor revisions.
2024-3-22: Submitted revised draft
2024-4-18: Received second review, reviewers 1, 3, and 4 all said yes, accepted.

Efficiency is high, processing time is within one month

(0) Thank | holida

This journal is unbelievable. It took nearly a month and a half for my R2 manuscript to be sent for review after submission to the editor. Can you believe it?

(0) Thank | 猪头猪脑

04.03 Finally changed from with editor to UR
Upon closer inspection, the editor invited a reviewer to continue reviewing my R2 revise manuscript.

截止到今天 04.10 The reviewer still hasn't accepted the review. This journal is really slow

(0) Thank | 猪头猪脑

2024.03.08 submitted to journal
2024.03.11 with editor
2024.03.29 It has been twenty days and it is still being edited

(0) Thank | 大陆北方网友

Hello, is there a fee for this journal?

(0) Thank | 爱吃橘子的猫

3.24 Still with editor. This journal is truly amazing

(0) Thank | 猪头猪脑

The manuscript R2 submitted on February 7th is still "with editor" as of today, without being sent for review, and the editor has not made a decision. It has been almost a month already. What's going on?

(0) Thank | 猪头猪脑

Extremely slow

(0) Thank | lunwen333

1.25 The result of the second review came back, with an additional reviewer suggesting rejection. The original reviewer recommended adding some content to the original manuscript. The editor has requested a revise.
2.7 Manuscript R2 has been submitted, entering the third round of review, currently with editor. Good luck, hoping for acceptance!

(0) Thank | 猪头猪脑

2024.1.5 Second Review RRC

(0) Thank | 猪头猪脑

Required Reviews Completed

(0) Thank | wanny233

Submission date: October 23, 2023
Review date: November 08, 2023
Awaiting review results

(0) Thank | wanny233

10.20 reviews completed --- revise 11.18之前提交 revised manuscript

(0) Thank | 猪头猪脑

This comment has been deleted!

(0) Thank | 猪头猪脑