I feel that it is still a very good journal, the processing efficiency is quite high, and it is not procrastinated. Unfortunately, it fell into Q3. I’m disappointed.

(2) Thank | 淦叭

Excuse me, everyone, how long does the reviewer invited status usually take? It has been in this state for more than 20 days. I found that the average review cycle given by Elsevier is only 1 month. Thank you.

(0) Thank | dingzongyu

It was my first time to submit to the journal, the efficiency of which was quite high. The questions raised by the two reviewers were more professional, compared to those of composite structure journals. The review comments were given in over 2 months, and it was accepted in less than 4 months. There are not many articles in this journal, and it is quite recognized in impact dynamics and engineering technology. If it is so fast in the future, the impact factor will definitely rise (although it fell in 2018). Recommend it.

(2) Thank | chriswang

Slow review but good overall quality. Generally about 3 months. Strict reviews with high quality experts. Thorough understanding of the problem.

(2) Thank | Anonymous

I would like to ask everyone, isn't the initial review of this journal supposed to be only 3 days? The submission deadline was 4-8, the deadline for the initial review was 4-11, and it still says "we". What does this mean? If it's not three days, could you please change the time? I'm in a hurry to graduate.

(0) Thank | Jason

Has the status of your paper "submitted to Journal" been ongoing for two months?

(0) Thank | horse

There is no point in saying more, submitted to the editor on 20250223 and still awaiting response.

(1) Thank | 空空孔

The first submission to IJIE took 221 days, with a complex and lengthy process. Thanks to the editors for their continuous efforts in finding reviewers, hoping that IJIE will continue to improve!

20240826 WE Submission
20240902 UR Invited 3
20241209 WE Invited a total of 6 reviewers in three months, no comments received
20250106 English customer service urging for revision
20250107 UR Invited 5 new reviewers
20250111 RRC Received 3 responses, 2 accepted
20250124 DIP Did not wait for the 3rd reviewer
20250203 16 major revisions
20250222 WE Revised
20250223 UR Invited 2
20250302 RRC
20250304 DIP
20250312 Minor revision based on 1 comment
20250313 WE invited 1 reviewer on the same day as UR
20250320 Comments returned but UR unchanged
20250403 DIP
20250404 Accept

(0) Thank | BIT-JZF

12.15 提交
12.15 编辑审阅
1.7 审阅中
2.18 待修订

(0) Thank | NB2023

Is it that slow?

(0) Thank | good 1

I am the same, it has been a long time, just missing one person.

(0) Thank | changlijun0814@163.com

After the rework, there are only two reviewers in total, one of whom has not responded for nearly three months. The reviewing speed is very slow, and it may lead to a delay in graduation.

(0) Thank | 回应

My name is also Dirk Mohr. The reviewer took three months to provide feedback and only returned the revised manuscript after being reminded once. It has been a month since the review was completed, and I have reminded them four or five times, but there has been no response yet.

(0) Thank | 物与理

For seven months in a year, rejection, the editing work efficiency is low. The reviewers found are far from the front line of scientific research, very incompetent, deliberately making things difficult. Have you studied mechanics to prove formulas derived from the assumption of linear elasticity?

(0) Thank | 黑黑小四

Was the submission rejected?

(0) Thank | www21

Rejected by the editor, reason: highlights exceed 85 characters.

(0) Thank | Delucc

Let's fight again. 
投:投稿 (submit an article)
送审:送审稿 (submit for review)

(0) Thank | changlijun0814@163.com

Is it that slow?? I saw on the journal's homepage that it takes about 127 days from submission to acceptance.

(0) Thank | 小千-21

Isn't it said on the journal's homepage that the Time to first decision is 3 days? I submitted on November 19th, got "With Editor" the next day, and it's still "With Editor" until now, it has been 10 days.

(0) Thank | 小千-21

10.26 Submitted
11.23 under review

Is the probability of rejection high for this journal? The previous submission was rejected after 6 months of external review, feeling really upset.

(0) Thank | www21

Just accepted today, the third reviewer has been refusing to review the manuscript. I sent an email today and Professor Mohr reviewed it himself and accepted it. Mohr is now using an MIT email, the one from ETH Zurich is no longer valid.

(0) Thank | yanglanfu

Hahaha, the OP's words are so funny.

(0) Thank | faegfearg

08.01 for review.

(0) Thank | changlijun0814@163.com

Hello, may I ask if you are the one who submitted the 3D printing column?

(0) Thank | rbf

24.07.23 submit
24.07.24 with editor

(0) Thank | rbf