There were 4 reviewers, 2 of them raise several minor revision suggestions. One thought the innovations of the article were not enough; the last one raised many comments (The data is not innovative enough, and the discussion part is relatively short); A total of 16 pages of revision comments were written. The comments raised by three reviewers were relatively acceptable; the other reviewer rejected it; the editor rejected it directly. The whole operation was relatively confusing.

(2) Thank | MISSH

On May 25th, submit; On May 28th, resubmit; On June 6th, under review; on July 3st, reject. There were four reviewers. Three reviewers gave praise (In Review Report Form, all the first column were selected, and there is only one selected in the second column at most) and one required revision (the second and third columns). The reason for the rejection of the manuscript was "Not much science related to theme of the journal." Conclusion: the editor casually rejected the manuscript. If you are still waiting two days after the status changes to the under review, you had better immediately seek another journal.

(5) Thank | 啊啊嘎嘎哈哈哈

Received: 2019.12.4; Accepted: 2020.1.10; Published: 2020.1.11. It took about 1 month from submission to acceptance, and a major revision was made during this period. The questions asked by the editor were also very professional, and the time given to revise the manuscript is very short. It seemed to be within a week. So if you want to submit to this journal, your own efficiency must be improved. If the article is in a hurry, you can consider submitting. The OA fee is about 10,000 yuan.

(2) Thank | biling

I have read several papers in this journal. Very fast. Open access.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Did you succeed in your investment?

(0) Thank | 123iceoutman

Got kicked

(0) Thank | 晏久

My paper was published around February 20th in WOS, but unfortunately it was not in SCI

(0) Thank | qianyu

What has not been included now will not be included in the future.

(0) Thank | wandaiji

The text is already in English.

(7) Thank | 明易

The databases are all owned by foreigners, so I can only say that it still depends on JCR.

(0) Thank | hy1983

The Chinese Academy of Sciences is really funny. Just as they removed the journal from the warning list in 2023, it was kicked out of SCI by WOS. It can only be said that MDPI's public relations with the Chinese Academy of Sciences are effective, but they can't handle foreigners! The warning journals of the Chinese Academy of Sciences are purely a joke.

(15) Thank | 爱浓醇

Dear partners, this journal is currently excluded from SCI SSCI. However, is there still a possibility of a successful appeal?

(5) Thank | 持续努力ing

Is this now a general publication? Isn't it the third district?

(0) Thank | Lucky

Just published and already a popular publication, it's really fucking exciting.

(6) Thank | six god

What has already been retrieved is definitely counted; what has been newly discovered is not counted.

(0) Thank | 洛轻尘

Is there still hope if mine is also missing one term of retrieval?!!!!

(0) Thank | BreatheSS

The publication made before May 22, 5 years ago, must be retrieved immediately, right? Can it not be retrieved later (based on the publication year)?

(0) Thank | 小迷糊呀

It depends on when you can get published. Currently, it seems that all submissions received by this journal from the end of January until now have not been indexed by SCI, and there is no indexing number. A indexing number is required in order to obtain an indexing certificate, which most schools recognize. You can verify whether it has been indexed by SCI (note that it is not just searchable in WoS, but must have an indexing number starting with "WoS"). If there is an indexing number starting with "WoS", immediately go to the school library to obtain an indexing certificate.

(0) Thank | Averyzx666

This question mainly asks about the policies of my own school.

(0) Thank | qiuer7

Is this kind of journal recognized by the school for graduation? (Currently, it can be found on Web of Science, and it has DOI and WoS.)

(0) Thank | 小迷糊呀

This question mainly asks about the policy of my own school.

(0) Thank | qiuer7

The impact of those already indexed by WOS is relatively small, but those that have not yet been indexed are lost.

(0) Thank | qiuer7

Does it have any impact on what was previously published?

(0) Thank | 小迷糊呀

Is the paper published in this journal before (which could be retrieved by web of science before), still considered as SCI now that the journal has been excluded from SCI? Can it still be counted as a graduation requirement?

(0) Thank | 小迷糊呀

Last year's article, I received information this year that it has been rejected by SCI. How did this happen?

(0) Thank | 518518