Rejected after waiting 5 months for first round review. They only sent it to one reviewer who rejected, but provided comments which I could have easily addressed in a round of revisions.

(0) Thank | Kris

It's very slow, it took three months before and after submission, with one minor revision and one major revision from external reviewers. Why was it rejected?

(0) Thank | Lianghj113

It's been over seven months, and finally it's back for repairs, just minor adjustments based on feedback from two reviewers. I have been waiting eagerly and finally my wish is granted, all the flowers that I have been waiting for have withered.

(0) Thank | 木子田心

Now that someone has checked the official website and found out the results, could they please clarify if it is District Two or District One?

(0) Thank | 木子田心

I found out in the early morning, but now it seems to have been blocked again. I heard that some big shots were not satisfied, hopefully it's the big shot of this publication. In the past, there have been cases of publications being demoted after being withdrawn from certain areas and then being promoted back.

(0) Thank | zz

The impact factor increased by 0.7, but the results dropped? It's ridiculous.

(0) Thank | Jayce~

Who said it has been downgraded? Where did you see that? Can't we still check it now that the system has just been uploaded?

(0) Thank | 木子田心

Oh no, I just got the results and they said I've been downgraded.

(0) Thank | zz

Wow, it's a disaster in 2025, and I haven't even graduated. It feels like the sky is falling.

(0) Thank | 求中

Submit by the end of 2024;
Send out for review on January 11, 2025;
Rejected on March 8, 2025;
Two reviewers, one accepted and one rejected, both provided detailed feedback.

(0) Thank | 我也不太了解她

I have been out for over a month, and the editor always replies with the same template. I don't even want to send it anymore.

(0) Thank | 多发论文哦

Have we got the results now? Has the editor replied?

(0) Thank | 小马不说话

It has been over a month since it was sent out for review and there has been no change. I tried to contact the editor but they have not responded. Is it difficult to find reviewers, or does the review process always take at least two months?

(0) Thank | 小马不说话

Hello, could you please share the LaTeX template for this journal?

(0) Thank | 沉冰

No, it's been almost half a year in just a few more days, and I still haven't received any response from the first trial. It's too slow.

(0) Thank | 木子田心

You've only been with the external audit for less than two months, starting from that day until today. The progress seems pretty good.

(0) Thank | 多发论文哦

Am I the slowest one? It's been 3 months and still no response from the first review.

(0) Thank | bzcars

Hello, may I ask if there are any results now? I have also been out for review for three months.

(1) Thank | bzcars

The journal conducts anonymous peer review, which I personally believe is very effective.

(0) Thank | 地遥求索者&Fu

I delayed the submission of my manuscript in December, gave thumbs up to the reviewers, and the manuscript is still under review during Christmas. Thumbs up to the editors too, as they are still sending out notifications over the weekend. Perhaps the big shots are all practicing finishing this year's work this year, which is worth learning from!

(0) Thank | 地遥求索者&Fu

This is taking forever, it's been almost five months and the repair hasn't been completed yet.

(0) Thank | 木子田心

04 October 2024
Manuscript Submitted
09 November 2024
Decision Pending
10 November 2024
Revision Required
19 November 2024
Revised Manuscript Submitted
19 November 2024
With Journal Administrator
21 November 2024
Manuscript Resubmitted
21 November 2024
With Journal Administrator
22 November 2024
With Editor
22 November 2024
Out for Review
......

(0) Thank | FourierWang

27 July 2024
With Editor
12 August 2024
Out for Review
16 August 2024
Decision Pending
25 August 2024
Revision Required
20 September 2024
Revision Incomplete
20 September 2024
Revised Manuscript Submitted
20 September 2024
With Journal Administrator
07 October 2024
With Editor
07 October 2024
Out for Review
14 October 2024
Decision Pending

(0) Thank | 大朗

Two reviewers provided specific revision suggestions, but the editor rejected them without apparent reason.

(0) Thank | tang11100

The current status is:
10 July 2024
With Editor
10 August 2024
Out for Review

(0) Thank | 波波你好吗