2020-06-07, submitted; 2020-06-12, rejected, suggested to resubmit; 2020-06-23, second submission; 2020-07-27, major revision, 6 reviewers; 2020-08-12, major revised manuscript was submitted; 2020-09-07, major revision. There were 4 reviewers (only one required major revision, and almost the others agreed to accept); 2020-09-20, major revised article was submitted; 2020-10-18, accepted. It is one of the top journals in the field of brain-computer interface, and the difficulty is still there. The reviewers were very serious. There were more than 150 questions were raised in total, and it was accepted after the questions were seriously answered. It relatively emphasizes on innovation, and it is very rigorous. It is my first time to have an article accepted by the top journal. The process was a little bumpy, but the result is more important.

(160) Thank | SWT

After submission, academic editor and responsible editor were arranged immediately. The speed was not bad, but I don’t know if it can be accepted. Major revision is also ok, but do not be rejected! I'm afraid of being rejected again.

(88) Thank | biAli

It was submitted to this journal yesterday, and there were an EIC and an ADM directly. Can I ask if it is normal that there is an additional ADM the next day, i.e. today?

(54) Thank | RZRW

Boss, may I ask if this journal will not change to "Under Review" from submission to Under Review until the first review results are returned, so it cannot be determined whether it is under external review?

(0) Thank | seuugtrgrt

How long does it usually take for a submission to go from "Ur" to "UR"? It has been a week and there has been no change.

(0) Thank | seuugtrgrt

The focus of our article is interdisciplinary, and the research content itself is relatively niche, so it can be understandable that the peer review process is slower. We submitted the article in early July 2024, received feedback in mid-December, underwent major revisions, with the feedback being objective and constructive. The revised article was accepted for publication one month later.

(0) Thank | 唐原

May I ask how long it takes for Ur to become UR?

(0) Thank | seuugtrgrt

It's really good to get the results in 3 months. I submitted in September and got rejected in March, almost 6 months in total. One of the reviewers pointed out that our article from March did not cite our manuscript from September. How could we cite a paper that was just published in March when we submitted our manuscript in September last year?

(0) Thank | 雾里看花1024

2025.1.9 拒绝

(0) Thank | shoulk

It has been over three months and there is still no feedback. The journal's reviewing speed has also slowed down.

(0) Thank | shoulk

May I ask what is your direction?

(0) Thank | 筝筝日上

2024.02.24 Submitted to journal
2024.09.05 Major revision, both reviewers have positive attitudes
2024.09.18 Submitted to journal
2024.09.26 Minor revision, reviewer 1 has three minor issues
2024.09.28 Submitted to journal
2024.10.15 Accepted

(0) Thank | enjoysnowing

Activity recognition using wearable sensors.

(0) Thank | zzzzME

2024.10.2 First draft of 10 pages, submitted for the first time.

(0) Thank | shoulk

Hello, what field is your paper in?

(0) Thank | zhenghaohao_hdu

Submitted on July 20th, rejected on October 5th with only one reviewer's opinion. The reason for rejection was to urge another reviewer, who never responded. Invitations were sent to other reviewers, but no one was willing to accept the review, so it was rejected. It's not even a niche field, so it's really frustrating.

(0) Thank | zzzzME

Did the external reviewers and associate editors reject it directly after submission? What were the reasons for the rejection?

(0) Thank | Kris000

2024.9.24 拒绝

(0) Thank | sasa_404

Please email the editor directly, he will return the paper and withdraw the submission information from the system. After you make the changes, you can resubmit it.

(0) Thank | lin

I have submitted to this journal before, so I can only wait.

(0) Thank | Socrates22333

How to proactively withdraw a submission?

(0) Thank | yyu1234

September 5, 2024 Under Review

(0) Thank | sasa_404

Submit on 5th September 2024.

(0) Thank | sasa_404

Ten pages need to include references. Generally, the page limits set by journals include references. For some journals, references may need to be on a separate page, as indicated.

(0) Thank | lin

Did you include references in the ten pages you modified?

(0) Thank | WhiteZhao