The journal review is very careful, the opinions are very pertinent, and systematic research and analysis are required to be accepted.

(3) Thank | peng

Both the first review and the second review lasted more than half a year, and it took more than one year in total. It was finally accepted. Thanks to the reviewers, the review comments were professional, which greatly helped improve the quality of the article.

(5) Thank | makeitbetter

Manuscripts submitted in June 2018; revision notice received at the end of April 2019. The three reviewers gave a good overall evaluation of the paper and a lot of revision comments. It was revised for one and a half months, and a large number of analyses and experiments were added. The revision comments were returned in early June. Accepted in the middle of July. Thanks to the reviewers for their professional comments, which greatly improved the quality of the paper.

(10) Thank | cdd

IEEE TKDE is undoubtedly the most authoritative journal in the field of data mining in the world, with a high reputation in the international arena. There have been many publications in the field of computers, but now many business schools in the United States have widely accepted them as a list of A-level journals in business schools in areas such as MIS/MS/OM/MEM.

(1) Thank | Anonymous

Incremental innovation is limited and experimentation is insufficient.

(0) Thank | Dylan_muc

Oh, what reason did you refuse?

(0) Thank | AQYH

Submission deadline: December 23, 2024
Rejection date: March 30, 2025

(0) Thank | Dylan_muc

It has been 7 months since the second trial. Was I forgotten because I used the old system to file my appeal?

(0) Thank | Clock966

What is the page limit for submitting a paper?

(0) Thank | StephenLee

What is the page limit for submissions to TKDE?

(0) Thank | StephenLee

Major revisions required on March 23, 2025. After waiting for nearly 8 months, the first round of review has finally been completed.

(0) Thank | XWZRBY

Share a failure case from some time ago:
2024.1.2 Submitted-Under Review
2024.1.31 Under review (lowercase review, sent for external review)
2024.2.20 Under Review (uppercase review, back to the editorial office)
2024.2.27 Reject
Three reviewers: 1 major revision, 1 minor revision, 1 rejection. The editor decided on rejection. The reviewer who recommended rejection said that the research topic of the manuscript should be submitted to an AI journal, as TKDE does not accept articles on AI applications. However, a few months later, I saw a review article related to my research area published in TKDE, which left me speechless. Although the review process was fast, the reviewers did not provide valuable feedback, suggesting not to submit if the direction is not strongly related or not within their community.

(0) Thank | 传奇耐拒王磕币·簿莱蒽忑

Oh, mine is the ScholarOne system, always in capital letters as UR.

(0) Thank | iorange2222

ScholarOne is the old submission system, while IEEE Author Portal is the new submission system. In the new system, the status will remain unchanged and will always be UR.

(0) Thank | AQYH

Which one is the new system and which one is the old system?

(0) Thank | iorange2222

The new system status has always been UR, while the old system has turned UR, not synchronized.

(0) Thank | AQYH

The expansion work in the cross direction has been rejected as out of scope after nearly 2 months of submission. The journal accepted a large number of papers in this direction last year, but has started to tighten its criteria this year.

(0) Thank | xxppxx00

Has there been any changes in the middle under review?

(0) Thank | Dylan_muc

One year is too long.

(0) Thank | 橙色小字

Submission on 2022.12.07
Major revision on 2023.06.02, minor revision on 2023.06.02
Revised submission on 2023.08.05
Accepted on 2023.11.11

(0) Thank | TeaseEmo

When were you rejected, and why do I see no change at all?

(0) Thank | Dylan_muc

What reason were you rejected for? I haven't made any moves yet, your number is ahead of mine.

(0) Thank | AQYH

I have been rejected for two months. The new system always shows "UR" in capital letters, and it won't change.

(0) Thank | leaderxtg

I also applied in December with an ID number over 3400, and I still have a UR status in capital letters.

(0) Thank | Dylan_muc

Oh, I also applied in January, with a score of over 300, and still waiting anxiously.

(0) Thank | 再让我中一次