2019/5/6 Submitted to the journal, 2019/6/26 Major revision, 2019/8/5 Submitted to the journal/Under review, 2019/8/31 Minor revision, 2019/9/1 Submitted to the journal/Under review, 2019/9/3 Awaiting Recommendation, 2019/9/7 Accept.

(9) Thank | skano

Antenna article, three reviewers, first review was three and a half months, all reviewers agree to accept.

(5) Thank | 司空菲离

Can I submit this for review now that it has passed the initial screening and is "Awaiting Editor Assignment"?

(0) Thank | 秋哥

Can I submit this for review now that it has passed the initial screening and is "Awaiting Editor Assignment"?

(0) Thank | 秋哥

Xiao Xiu's email mentioned that when returning for revision, a combined PDF (including the main text and author response) should be uploaded in the corresponding place. However, in the new system, it is displayed as separate uploads. Therefore, I uploaded them separately, which resulted in the author response not being included in the "view submission" file. Will this have any impact? /(ㄒoㄒ)/~~

(0) Thank | ron9685

Hello, may I ask if this has any impact? In the email, it was mentioned to upload a combined PDF in the appropriate place, but I uploaded them separately, which caused the author response to not appear in the "view submission" file.

(0) Thank | ron9685

Can you explain why my AR status changed to "under review" again? I am also experiencing the same situation.

(0) Thank | Trex137

The communication submitted on December 12th, 24, has not received the first review yet. I followed up with the editor two weeks ago, and they replied that it is still under review. It feels even slower than a long article.

(0) Thank | QqZzzzze

The new system is too basic, lacking detailed status information.

(0) Thank | Heyuuuuu

The submission on December 28, 2024 is still under review.

(0) Thank | amor00

Not yet, it's all luck. It can change to "awaiting decision" in 3 days. I've experienced it, changing in 3 weeks as well. After all, we have to wait for both AE and TE to make a decision. No one knows which one of them will delay.

(0) Thank | xysun1204

Have the results come out yet? How long does it take to receive the recommendation?

(0) Thank | 凛冬已至1996

February 21, 2025 submission, has been under view all the time.

(0) Thank | 半半小生

2024.12.04 submit
2024.12.26 Under review
2025.02.21 Awaiting Recommendation

Sigh, I have never received a first review result within two months. I really envy those who get results in just over 40 days.

(0) Thank | xysun1204

2024-06-06 submit to communication
2024-08-02 awaiting recommendation
2024-09-05 major revision
2025-01-02 resubmit
2025-01-20 awaiting recommendation
2025-01-27 accept

(0) Thank | ddanp2013

The time given to reviewers is the same, 28 days. With luck, completing one round of finding reviewers can be done in just over a month.

(0) Thank | 123xxx

We submitted our work in July, and it is still under review. We contacted the editorial board twice. Although they said they are sorry and are trying to expedite the review process, we still have not received the first-round review. It has been almost six months, and it is very disappointing.

(0) Thank | Gaussian

Communication with the tap has been sent, but there has been no response for a month. It is still under review.

(0) Thank | 雨黎

Has anyone submitted to TAP's communication? How fast is the reviewing process?

(0) Thank | QqZzzzze

12.4 submission, the old system saw that it entered UR today.

(0) Thank | SYY

2024.4.16 submitted (submitted in the new system IEEE Author Portal, personally I feel that the new system submission is much more convenient, but the review status is more detailed in the old system)
2024.6.8 major revision (there were a total of three reviewers, their comments were relatively fair, although the Associate Editor raised quite a few questions)
2024.8.29 resubmitted
2024.9.18 major revision (the second review was quite fast, with a reply in just over half a month, there were not many comments left, mainly requesting me to supplement the content in the response letter in the paper)
2024.10.24 resubmitted
2024.11.13 accepted (total duration of 7 months, with 4 months spent on two revisions, the reviewers and AE were very professional and responsible, placing a strong emphasis on the novelty and practicality of the theoretical analysis and innovative points)

(0) Thank | 风盈随峰

After the new system is submitted, the UR will be displayed, and the old system can also see the detailed process synchronously. If it has been two months, you can ask the editor. However, the editor may not reply.

(0) Thank | czcz

Hello, I have been submitting for 2 months in the new system, but it still shows "ur". The old system does not have any information on this article. What does it look like after you submit? How long does it take to find the message in the old system?

(0) Thank | svsav

Modified two rounds, took 7 months, and in the end, they rejected it, saying that some performance was not good. No response to the appeal...

(0) Thank | czcz

Have you received early access yet? I received mine on the 10th, the DOI was issued on the 18th, but still no early access on the 26th!

(0) Thank | Heu