The manuscript was submitted on May 15, 2019; recommendation of major revisions returned on October 14th; I returned the revised manuscript on November 15th and was given notification of acceptance on December 8.

(0) Thank | Erinsilly

Heat and Mass Transfer is a journal that has an important influence in the field of heat and mass transfer. It publishes 157 papers per year, much less than Int. J. Heat and Mass Transfer. However, the quality of the paper is high, so the review process is very long, which reflects the German principle of doing things diligently. I have published two papers in this journal, and the review period is about 6-8 months. The review time of most journals has become significantly longer. I wish you all the best.

(0) Thank | 日照龙麟万点金

Too slow!!! It's been a month and the editor still hasn't been assigned!!! And the website has been down for two days!!!

(0) Thank | Zheng_W_L

Area 4 can choose OA, but it is very expensive and not internationally popular for heat and mass transfer

(0) Thank | 加速过弯

2023.4.12 Submission,
2023.4.18 Editor assigned
2023.5.18 Reminder, no response received
2023.6.5 Reminder, no response received
2023.6.15 Rejection (The rejection email is templated and exactly the same as the rejection content sent to a previous senior student).

(0) Thank | 随缘随心

It is indeed too slow, and they do not respond to the urging for the submission. It is the same situation as mine.

(0) Thank | huyugan

2023.4.12 Submitted,
2023.4.18 Editor Assigned,
Today (2023.6.12) still Editor Assigned, this journal is too slow.

(0) Thank | 随缘随心

A bit slow, but quite rigorous, with additional reviewers added in between. The editor is from Germany.
1.29 submitted
4.5 under review
5.6 reviews completed
5.11 major revision
5.24 submit
6.1 reviewer assigned
6.7 under review
8.25 minor revision
8.28 submitted
8.29 editor assigned then under review
9.25 major revision
10.1 submitted
10.10 under review
11.8 accepted
11.29 online

(0) Thank | jinxie

03 Jun - Submission
19 Aug - Major overhaul
02 Dec - Minor repair
06 Dec - Hiring

(0) Thank | JOJO-YY

12 5 2021 - Editor Decision - Accept
19 3 2021 - AU - Author Revision
25 Feb 2021 - Editor decision - Major Revision
13 9 2020 - AU - Author Revision
07 9 2020 - Editor decision - Major Revision
05 9 2020 - AU - Author Revision
17 8 2020 - Editor decision - Major Revision
16 7 2020 - AU - Author Submission
The speed of the modifications is a bit slow, and the journal does not allow photos to be included.

(0) Thank | 锅炉工作者

Journal is very strict, mainly accepting research on heat and mass transfer theory.However, if the innovation is very strong, the application papers are accepted.Submission time: 2015.11, distribution review time: 2016.2, review draft conclusion reply: 2016.3.2, request overhaul, 2016.3.6, revised, re-submitment, 2016.3.10 accepted.

(0) Thank | 扫地僧

online, how long does it usually take to publish?

(0) Thank | xslbill

Editor-in-chief is very good, very professional, drafted in December last yearIn April this year, the review comments were overhauled, and the revised draft was uploaded in early June. July 4th accepted.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

I was a brother in 11 years and August.It was not the usual slowness to receive the first revision opinion last month.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Submission confirmed after two months, under review, there is no news yet.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

What I did was the heat and mass transfer of the geotechnical medium. The overall speed was relatively slow. From submission to recruitment for 11 months, it was modified twice

(0) Thank | Anonymous

The editing process is very slow, and the manuscript waited for two months before being sent to the editorial department for review.It took nearly a year from submission to recruitment.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

I also collapsed. My manuscript was selectd in December 2011, and under review in January 12, there is no news yet.Impressed.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

is a bit slow, from submission to receiving one year and six months

(0) Thank | Anonymous

submitted in October 2011, it has been 7 months, still under reviewReally served

(0) Thank | Anonymous

selectd for a month, have not reviewed the manuscript!It’s really not slow.10 months to receive the modification notice.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Journal Homepage URL: http://www.springer.com/engineering/mechanical+eng/journal/231

(0) Thank | Anonymous

submitted an article, 6 monthsIt has not been reviewed yet.It may be that the content of my article is controversial.Published.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Feels a little slow ah

(0) Thank | Anonymous

heat transfer and mass transfer》Germany ISSN: 0947-7411, started in 1968, 8 issues throughout the year, published by Springer-VerlagSociety.SCI, EI journals, SCI 2002 impact factor 0.477, 2003 EI included 115 articles.A report on the basics and applications of heat transfer and mass transfer phenomena, as well as the properties of related materials and their testing.

(0) Thank | Anonymous