I have reviewed manuscripts several times for this journal; two weeks were given for the reviewers. The articles I received had some innovation, but I felt that the writing and figures were quite normal, and the preparation before submission was not very sufficient. The editorial office is quite tolerant of manuscripts. They will not invite a bunch of reviewers, and there are always two. When the reviewer's opinions are one positive and one negative, the manuscript will not be easily rejected, and it will be judged by the editorial board personally.

(25) Thank | 飘云

Excuse me, when I submitted manuscripts to other journals, it showed the status of with editor, under review, etc. Now the status of the manuscript submitted to ERL has always been Manuscript Received. Do you know whether it has been sent for review?

(9) Thank | earthresearch

03-May-2020 Submitted; 12-Jun-2020 Moderate Revision; 01-Jul-2020 Submitted Revised Manuscript; 10-Jul-2020 Formal Accept.

(5) Thank | 你好啊

Good journal in environment science.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

Can the content of the submitted paper exceed 4000 words?

(0) Thank | #QVQ#

Hello, I can see in the system that the status has changed to "provisionally accepted", but I have not received any email notification. May I ask about your situation?

(0) Thank | 林宇艾

The process is very fast, and the editors and reviewers are also very nice.
Submitted on July 25th, revised on August 13th, revised again on August 20th, accepted on September 4th, published on September 12th.

(0) Thank | Joyhang

Hello, is the article required to be within 4000 words?

(0) Thank | Rudy

Is it required that empirical articles submitted to this journal must be no more than 4000 words?

(0) Thank | hahahaha

It's been 13 days already, still Mr. Tell me if your status has changed, bro

(0) Thank | 彦祖

Hello, do you have an update now? I saw that the average time for the first review of the journal is 4 days, but it's already the 5th day and the status is still "manuscript received."

(0) Thank | getmanysci

Hello, have you received any updates yet? I noticed that the average first review time for the journal is 4 days, but it's already the 5th day and the status is still "manuscript received."

(0) Thank | getmanysci

It has been over 10 days since submission, but the status is still Manuscript Received. Can anyone share what's going on?

(0) Thank | 彦祖

Is there still a word limit for this journal? I couldn't find it in the author services, but I remember there used to be an 8000-word limit

(0) Thank | SPNAIL

Very good journal, with high quality articles and professional reviewers. Just a bit slow in the review process

(10) Thank | SYUEJD

2023.09.24 Submission
2023.11.07 Minor revisions
2023.11.29 Major revisions
2023.12.14 Acceptance
2023.12.18 Official acceptance

(1) Thank | UV250

How long does it take for the official employment after being provisionally accepted by the employer?

(0) Thank | 多里

Congratulations, was it difficult?

(0) Thank | ikun111

How long does it take to go from Provisionally Accepted to Formal Accepted?

(0) Thank | dfbsjfwkbf

November 2022 Submission
March 2023 Major Repair
June 2023 Acceptance

(6) Thank | 蔚茫

Original text: 楼主，请问ERL大修后是直接接收，还是经过了小修后才接收的？

Translation: Excuse me, host, may I ask if ERL is directly accepted after major repairs or is it accepted only after minor repairs?

(0) Thank | 果叔

Overall, it is speeding up.

(0) Thank | 依缘

2023.3.9 Hired!

(0) Thank | Haruka

2023-01-03 Posting
2023-02-08 Major Renovation

(0) Thank | Haruka

Does not include, summary is also not included.

(0) Thank | Mcflyy