2020.5.25 submission; 2020.7.22 major revision; 2020.10.17 revised submission; 2020.11.5 accepted. The direction is biomedical signal processing, and human physiological parameter detection. I personally think that the innovation of this article is moderately low. There were 2 reviewers in total. It may be that the reviewer’s questions were answered in a detailed manner, with more than 20 pages of responses, so it was directly accepted after the revised submission of the first review, which was quite smooth. A very good submission experience.

(25) Thank | 荣猛

It is a very memorable article; it is about medical image processing, and it is considered to take the interdisciplinary advantage. The first time I got the review comments, I found that there were 7 reviewers. This is the time I encountered most reviewers ever. The statuses of the article were attached. 4.22, submitted to journal; 4.28, with editor; 5.1, under review; 5.10, under editor evaluation; 5.11, with editor; 6.5, major revision; 9.4, revision submitted to journal; 9.8, with editor; 9.8, under review; 9.16, with editor; 9.18, minor revision; 9.21, revision submitted to journal; 9.21, with editor; 9.25, under review; 10.12, with editor; 10.13, accept.

(11) Thank | Dr. Strange

2019.2.20 Submission; 2019.10.10 It was hard for me to wait for the first review comments while I sent three reminder letters. 2019.11.16 Comments came back; 2019.11.23 Sent for review; 2019.12.08 Acceptance.

(1) Thank | flye e e e

I waited around 4 months to receive the first reviews of my thesis. However, it was worth the wait because my paper was accepted pending revisions! After addressing the reviewer’s edits and comments, my paper was accepted. It was published online within one month.

(1) Thank | hfxjxu

Teacher, should we withdraw this submission? It feels like we have been waiting for too long.

(0) Thank | 咖啡水晶

I am a medical image classifier.

(0) Thank | 咖啡水晶

Submitted on 2.27, it is still in the "we" stage. How long will it take to be "ur" approximately?

(0) Thank | nic_1112

Still no changes, I didn't dare to push for submission, afraid that I would be rejected as soon as I did.

(0) Thank | 竹本

Have you received a reply? My status is the same.

(0) Thank | 一束花送你

Medical image segmentation

(0) Thank | zzt

What major are you studying, classmate?

(0) Thank | 521

24-6-6 with editor
24-7-4 under review, accepted by 2 reviewers, one completed the review on the same day
24-7-7 under review, accepted by the third reviewer, but both reviewers disappeared
24-10-22 under review, a new set of reviewers were invited, but none accepted
24-12-6 under review, another set of reviewers were invited, one accepted
25-1-6 rc
25-1-7 dip
25-1-24 major
25-2-27 resubmit
25-2-28 under review
25-3-2 under review, the second reviewer completed the review. The first reviewer never responded to the invitation, having completed their review in July last year. It seems they forgot about the article after such a long time.
25-3-28 rc, luckily the first reviewer saw the email and remembered, didn't disappear, otherwise a new one would have to be found
25-3-29 dip
25-4-14 accept

The dip period always lasts a long time, it feels like the editor works only once every two weeks. I've seen many cases on Little Red Book and here where people kept dipping like me, and they all got accepted on the same day. So it's purely luck, if you're lucky, you submit today and the editor works tomorrow, if you're unlucky, the editor worked yesterday, so you might have to wait for half a month.

(0) Thank | zzt

@One by one, medical image segmentation direction.

(0) Thank | treyguo

Can I ask which direction is convenient?

(0) Thank | 一篇一篇又一篇

Update: Today accepted for 4/14/2025. Sent email reminder four days ago.

(0) Thank | treyguo

Can I ask all the students, how long did it take for you to review the manuscript? Generally, after accepting an invitation, how many days does it take for reviewers to complete the review?

(3) Thank | 521

Yes, it is the second trial.

(0) Thank | Nix

Excuse me, are you in the second review? Can you share the timeframe?

(0) Thank | 521

23 days have passed and we are still in a dip.

(0) Thank | Nix

I have been working on it for over a month and it hasn't been submitted for review yet. Can I ask what direction your paper is in?

(0) Thank | 一篇一篇又一篇

I would like to ask if you have submitted for review, teacher? I have been waiting for 20 days and my submission is still in the process.

(0) Thank | 咖啡水晶

The median for the First Decision on the journal's official website has reached 26 days.

(0) Thank | 一篇一篇又一篇

It has been over 20 days since I submitted my paper to DIP. I have sent an email to the Editor but have not received a response.

(0) Thank | Nix

@treyguo, no, 25-4-9, still DIP, graduation materials need to be submitted, no response after two reminders to the editor. Went to a water conference.

(0) Thank | 因为雨回下

@treyguo, no, 25-4-9, still DIP, graduation materials need to be submitted, no response after two reminders to the editor. Went to a water meeting.

(0) Thank | 因为雨回下