I am one of three reviewers, each of us asks around 10 questions.

(0) Thank | sjtutyq

How many reviewers are usually involved in the review process?

(0) Thank | kkxu

Second review:
Decision Sent to Author 21st Aug 24 00:27:47 (acceptance)
Waiting to Send Decision to Author 16th Aug 24 08:02:27
Manuscript Under Consideration 15th Aug 24 21:38:48
Manuscript Under Consideration 31st Jul 24 09:33:26
Editor Assigned 29th Jul 24 06:13:58
Manuscript Received 29th Jul 24 06:13:57

(0) Thank | sjtutyq

First Review:
Revision Received 29th Jul 24 05:52:41 (major revised)
Waiting for Revision 17th Jun 24 08:07:30
Decision Sent to Author 17th Jun 24 08:07:30
Waiting to Send Decision to Author 14th Jun 24 06:21:15
Manuscript Under Consideration 13th Jun 24 20:32:17
Manuscript Under Consideration 13th May 24 06:21:17
Editor Assigned 10th May 24 00:17:19
Manuscript Received 10th May 24 00:17:19

(0) Thank | sjtutyq

Will the collection be faster? Have you submitted it? Share some experience, brother.

(0) Thank | kkxu

Both innovation and integrity require high standards, with reviewers being highly professional and possessing strong control abilities. Only submissions to professional journals in the npj series are accepted by the flagship journal. Submitting to NC comprehensive journals requires additional supplements, collaboration, financial investment, and increased workload. Otherwise, one may consider submitting to other publishing companies. Due to the reputation of the Nature publishing group and its global peer review system, it is preferable to submit to the npj series for high global peer recognition.

(0) Thank | qweruiop

Will the submission collection special issue be faster? How long does it take for the editor-in-chief's initial review?

(0) Thank | Peteretal

Decision Sent to Author	30th Jan 24 02:51:23 (Reject)
Waiting to Send Decision to Author	29th Jan 24 03:34:49
Manuscript Under Consideration	22nd Jan 24 23:02:43
Manuscript Under Consideration	29th Dec 23 01:18:51
Editor Assigned	28th Dec 23 10:37:52
Manuscript Received	28th Dec 23 10:37:51
Left in the editor's hands for a month, directly rejected, editor with no integrity, everyone please do not submit, a huge waste of time

(1) Thank | xiaozi

The manuscript under consideration may not necessarily be sent for review, as the editor may choose to pre-screen it

(2) Thank | zhgong007

Manuscript Under Consideration
Is this status in the editing process or under review?

(0) Thank | WC868

Third review:
Decision sent to Author on August 20th (Accepted)
Decision sent to Author on August 20th
Waiting to send Decision to Author on August 20th
Manuscript under consideration on August 18th
Editor assigned on August 11th
Manuscript received on August 11th

(4) Thank | 木色cc

Second Review:
Revision Received 11th Aug
Waiting for Revision 10th Aug (Principle Accepted)
Decision Sent to Author 10th Aug 22
Waiting to Send Decision to Author 9th Aug 22
Manuscript Under Consideration 8th Aug 22
Manuscript Under Consideration 27th Jul 22
Editor Assigned 26th Jul 22
Manuscript Received 26th Jul 22

(0) Thank | 木色cc

First review:
Revision Received 26th Jul 22
Waiting for Revision 12th Jul 22 (Major Revised)
Decision Sent to Author 12th Jul 22
Waiting to Send Decision to Author 12th Jul 22
Manuscript Under Consideration 12th Jul 22
Manuscript Under Consideration 6th Jun 22
Editor Assigned 3rd Jun 22
Manuscript Received 3rd Jun 22

(2) Thank | 木色cc

It turns out to be the first review. Since it is published by Nature, the control over the quality of the article is quite strict, so the chance of being reviewed is relatively low. There is still a chance for works that are done systematically and have higher innovation. The review process is not very fast, and most of the time is spent in the hands of the editors. The publication cycle is relatively long.

(11) Thank | zhgong007