Submitted on January 9, 2025
Reviewed on January 14, 2025
First reviewer reviewed on January 15, 2025
First reviewer completed review on January 16, 2025
Second reviewer reviewed on January 18, 2025
Second reviewer left on February 8, 2025
Editor invited third reviewer overnight on February 8, 2025
Third reviewer reviewed on February 9, 2025
Third reviewer completed review on February 21, 2025
Editor processed review comments that night (major revision) on February 21, 2025
Revised response to review comments on February 23, 2025
All reviewers responded on March 2, 2025
Editor processed on March 2, 2025
Accepted at 1:00 AM on March 3, 2025
Proofreading on March 4, 2025
The editor is very efficient and friendly, so I suggest everyone submit their work.

(0) Thank | 123

What are the results? Will the application be directly rejected or decided to be reviewed?

(0) Thank | BINGOSIX

Thanks to the good guidance of my postdoctoral supervisor.

(0) Thank | 小白001

Little White is so amazing to have accepted so quickly!

(0) Thank | shimin_7

Little Bai is so talented to catch on so quickly.

(0) Thank | shimin_7

The time was mistaken, the submission deadline is December 31, 2024.

(0) Thank | 小白001

Submission deadline: December 31, 2023;
Sent for review to two reviewers on January 15, 2025;
Revised and submitted on February 14, 2025;
Accepted on February 17, 2023;
The journal has a particularly fast processing efficiency, it's a good journal, hopefully its Impact Factor will increase soon.

(0) Thank | 小白001

The editing process was quick, and the reviewers' comments were very targeted and fair. Although the reviewers questioned whether our experimental results were due to component errors, they also provided an opportunity for major revisions. After responding promptly, our paper was quickly accepted. Overall, the submission experience was great!

(0) Thank | zzzZzZit

The overall speed of MTP is very fast, with the submission to acceptance taking just over a month. The suggestions from the two reviewers were also very insightful, and the paper was published immediately after acceptance.

Timeline:
10.22 Submit
10.27 Under Review
11.13 Major Revision
11.24 Resubmit
12.05 Accept

(0) Thank | Ushuaia

How did it turn out in the end, were you rejected?

(0) Thank | Lity

Did it become Dip after submitting directly with the editor, or did it become Dip after submitting 15 directly and then 16 becoming Dip?

(0) Thank | Lity

No, you can see the progress by registering an account with the submission mailbox.

(0) Thank | greedyboy

I want to ask, is it only through communication that I can check the progress? My supervisor submitted it for me today, but I haven't received the password. What should I do to check the progress? Can you please reply to me? Do I need to register myself?

(0) Thank | hyj

I want to ask, is it only through communication that progress can be checked? My supervisor submitted it for me today, but I haven't received the password. What's going on and how can I check the progress? Can you please reply?

(0) Thank | hyj

I want to ask, is it only through communication that I can check the progress? My supervisor submitted it for me today, but I haven't received the PASSWORD. What's going on?

(0) Thank | hyj

I didn't understand what the person upstairs was saying. I work in flexible electronics.

(0) Thank | greedyboy

Can you bring the up? Do we need to include additional documents?

(0) Thank | Fear-Jun-dreams

Received the review comments on 5.31, with two reviewers suggesting major revisions within one month. Responded to the review comments on 6.26, and the paper was accepted on 6.28. Grateful for the editors and reviewers.

(0) Thank | greedyboy

Submitted to accepted 17 days.

(0) Thank | voyage

It has been over a month since Xiao Xiu submitted his article to the journal

(1) Thank | 康师傅脑残酸菜面

Two reviewers accepted the review, one of them finished reviewing the next day, and the other has not finished reviewing until now, wasting the time saved by the first reviewer. Hope for a good result

(0) Thank | greedyboy

Just after posting an inquiry thread, I received a rejection notice and was advised to submit to another journal, with a recommended one provided. All this happened within a 5-day timeframe

(0) Thank | 可爱熊001

How long did it take for you to receive the rejection letter? I’m in the same situation as you, my submission became DIP on the fourth day. I want to switch my submission, but I haven't received a rejection letter yet, so I'm hesitant to take action

(0) Thank | 可爱熊001

5.18 Submitted for Review

(0) Thank | greedyboy

After delivery, it is directly DIP, without even looking at it, but the speed is quite fast

(0) Thank | Spike