Dear friends, the article was submitted a month ago, the confidential review was sent to them the day before yesterday, the status was displayed as “with editor” yesterday, and then the it changed to “Decision in Process”. Does it mean that the manuscript has been rejected? Please give me some advice. Thank you all.

(2) Thank | 战忽局列兵

It is indeed faster than other similar journals. It is slower due to the epidemic, and the normal processing time should be 2–3 months. The post-acceptance processing is very fast, which is much faster than a certain British journal that I submitted earlier. In short, it is quite fast.

(4) Thank | slump

Submitted on April 20, 2019. A major revision and two minor revisions. Decisions are still pending by now that it has been for 9 days until September 7th. It is said that since this journal was promoted as SCIE, many people contribute articles. The editorial aboard was unable to publish the articles with a backlog of articles. If you want to graduate, it is estimated that the turnaround time from submission to acceptance and publication will not be less than 8 months. It is recommended to consider other journals. However, you can consider this journal if not in hurry.

(58) Thank | 飞鱼阿占

Before, I thought a certain journal was too slow, always "with editor", neither sending for review nor rejecting the submission, so I withdrew the submission. After the website showed the withdrawal was completed, I resubmitted to this journal without mentioning the withdrawal situation in the cover letter. The editor rejected the submission citing this reason, saying it was academically unethical. I find it puzzling how this label is applied, is this the arrogance of domestic journals?

(1) Thank | 星踪

Promoted to level one.

(0) Thank | 一二三四

I used to charge 750 per page, but now it should be unified to charge per article, around 13,000 words per article.

(0) Thank | 星踪

You can check the journal's official website, I have not used the public account before.

(0) Thank | 一二三四

Can DT inquire about the review progress on the Elsevier public account?

(0) Thank | 顺遂

Three reviewers, two major revisions were directly rejected, and one minor revision was rejected by the editor. The number of published articles in that year was around 90 or 120, and I estimate that I was squeezed out by favoritism. Another article submitted to CJA also took three months to receive feedback from one reviewer with two comments, which was a waste of time. After polishing these two articles, both were accepted for publication. I will try my best to avoid submitting to domestic journals in the future.

(0) Thank | 扶风牧云

How much is the layout fee?

(0) Thank | 赵2024

About a month.

(0) Thank | 星踪

September 7th submission
September 12th with editor
September 12th submitted for confidentiality review
September 20th under review
October 31st Required Reviews Completed
October 31st Decision in Process
November 3rd Major revision
November 14th revision submitted to journal
November 14th under review after with editor
December 13th Decision in Process
December 24th Email proofreading
December 25th Acceptance

(0) Thank | 一二三四

December 24th received the revised draft by email.

(0) Thank | 一二三四

Have you been rejected for four months? How long does the first trial take?

(0) Thank | TATB

A journal with no academic value, just an internal game.

(0) Thank | MoreSci啊

This journal is still relatively influential in the industry and belongs to the top journals in the industry. I hope that it can be further categorized by the Chinese Academy of Sciences this year. I also hope that it can smoothly...

(0) Thank | 一二三四

After submitting the manuscript, the author called the editorial office due to a long "with editor" status and found out that the manuscript had been overlooked. It was only after the phone call that the manuscript was processed.

One month after the first "under review" status, an email was sent to inquire about the status of the review process, shortly after it changed to "DIP".

One month after the second "under review" status, another email was sent to inquire about the status of the review process, and the next day the status changed to "DIP".

(0) Thank | 一二三四

September 7th submitted
September 12th with editor
September 12th submitted for confidential review
September 20th under review
October 31st Required Reviews Completed
October 31st Decision in Process
November 3rd Major revision
November 14th revision submitted to journal
November 14th under review after with editor
December 13th Decision in Process

(0) Thank | 一二三四

How long does it usually take to receive the proof after accepting it, and approximately how much does it cost?

(0) Thank | 万万没想到

Excuse me, how long does it usually take to receive the proof after accepting it, and when should I make the payment?

(0) Thank | 万万没想到

Not yet in the hands of the editor.

(0) Thank | www21

Can you check if this email is the one that sends back the track for review?

(0) Thank | www21

Accepted after revision, it will be published two months after acceptance.

(0) Thank | 爆炸冲击波

Hello, what's the matter with not having an article number after submission? Do we have to wait for a period of time before receiving the number? Also, one of the co-authors did not receive the email to confirm, will this have any impact? Thank you!

(0) Thank | NUAA卢本伟

It took a total of three months to finally be accepted. Now it is in the second district of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, hoping to do better and better.

submitted to journal 2024-04-30
editor in chief 2024-05-06
with editor 2024-05-06
under review after submitting for confidentiality review 2024-05-07
under review 2024-05-24
Major revision 2024-06-20
Revision Submitted to Journal 2024-06-27
with editor 2024-06-28
under review 2024-06-28
Minor revision 2024-07-03
Revision Submitted to Journal 2024-07-03
Decision in process 2024-07-05
Accept 2024-07-24

(0) Thank | 白杨战风沙