It is a very good journal with fast review speed. The result of the external review was given in one month and a half, and it was accepted in two months and a half.

(12) Thank | 一只特立独行的猪2020

Super slow, under review for over 3 months, the first review has not been completed yet.

(0) Thank | 好运好运来

I have been waiting for the first review comments for four months since submission. The articles recently accepted have all taken around six months.

(0) Thank | 一颗冉冉升起的新星

How long have you been investing? Other comments seem to be quite quick. I am planning to invest soon.

(0) Thank | 滴哩哩哩滴哩哩哩哒哒

How come the review process of this journal is so slow now? It used to be fast before. Now, all the flowers waiting for submission are withering as we are in a hurry to graduate.

(0) Thank | 一颗冉冉升起的新星

May I ask how to choose the classification of research when submitting a manuscript?

(0) Thank | 贰拾

The domestic journal feels pretty good, it took less than 3 months to receive the acceptance, and the reviewers are quite responsible. I hope domestic journals will continue to improve!

(0) Thank | wanglu37

Just wanted to ask, for submitting to this journal, should text and graphics be uploaded separately? Can the manuscript not contain any graphics?

(1) Thank | maybe321

The Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences ranks top in the field of forestry and forestry ecology, with good recognition. The time from submission to acceptance is close to 4 months, which is quite good for a top-tier journal.

2024.4.9: Submit manuscript to journal
2024.4.18: Under review
2024.5.24: Major revise
2024.7.2: Revise version submit to journal
2024.7.18: Minor revise
2024.7.31: Revise version submit to journal
2024.7.31: Accept

(2) Thank | 会飞的小海龟

Can't you find the number and progress of submissions in UR status? Isn't this an Elsevier platform? Can't find it in the public account.

(0) Thank | mumu12345

It is better to upload charts and text separately

(0) Thank | 一棵认真生长的树

You can contact the editorial department at 010-62337915, or send an email to forestecosystems@bjfu.edu.cn, and ask the editor to help you with a detailed search for where the problem lies

(0) Thank | 一棵认真生长的树

Regular papers nowadays do not accept co-first authorship, unless they are large collaborative papers involving multiple institutions

(0) Thank | 一棵认真生长的树

You can contact the editorial office at 010-62337915, or email forestecosystems@bjfu.edu.cn, for the editor to help you with a detailed inquiry about where the issue lies, which should be resolved quickly

(0) Thank | 一棵认真生长的树

You can contact the editorial office at 010-62337915, or email forestecosystems@bjfu.edu.cn, and ask the editor to help you with a detailed investigation of where the problem lies. It should be resolved relatively quickly

(0) Thank | 一棵认真生长的树

Usually 2-3 reviewers are invited. Sometimes invited reviewers accept or decline the review, and the system will show changes

(0) Thank | 一棵认真生长的树

My item has been repaired already, quite fast

(0) Thank | 会飞的小海龟

What's going on, I've been waiting for UR for two months already, the submission time has been changed 3 times, still no news

(0) Thank | mumu12345

How many reviewers does this journal usually invite?

Submission on 4/8/2024
Under review on 4/12/2024
Changed to under review on 4/18/2024

(1) Thank | 会飞的小海龟

Submitted in early January, it took three months for external review, with one acceptance and one rejection. The editor provided feedback on the rejected submission

(2) Thank | whywhywhy11111

How can I proceed? Thank you~

(1) Thank | 会飞的小海龟

Submitted on November 27th, 23, it became Under Review approximately three days later, and has been UR ever since for over two months. The time has changed a few times in between, it changed once on January 19th, and once on February 2nd. I hope for a positive outcome

(1) Thank | zjshi

Hello, may I ask how much the final layout fee was?

(0) Thank | 史森

Hello, how long will "with editor" last?

(0) Thank | 学习日记

Not exceeding two weeks.

(0) Thank | 一棵认真生长的树