How did your status change? My status changed from Submitted to Journal to with editor, and then back to Submitted to Journal. Is it a tragedy?

(1) Thank | xiaoqi325

The review is very professional, the standards are high, it is hard to succeed without depth

(0) Thank | yangxinghai514

Posted on June 21st
With editor on June 26th
Rejected on June 29th, reason: The article lacks relevant research and depth.

(1) Thank | 补刀12

May I ask how is the review speed of this magazine? I have not received any updates for my submission in a week.

(0) Thank | 补刀12

This journal is more suitable for publication by top-notch teams.

(0) Thank | 甜玉米

May I ask if it has been one week since submission and it still says "Submitted"? It's a bit slow.

(2) Thank | 安徽农业大学许辉

Rejected three days after the format was changed and submitted.

(2) Thank | 果果一枚

There are some formatting issues, and they have been corrected and resubmitted.

(0) Thank | 果果一枚

Translate the following text into English: If there is no external review and the paper goes directly to DIP, there are two possible situations: first, it can be rejected directly; second, it can be rejected and resubmitted. This is purely my personal inference! Other situations are also possible.

(0) Thank | 祖一丁

May I ask if the result is rejection? I also entered the decision phase directly one week after submitting the manuscript.

(0) Thank | 果果一枚

Excuse me, did you submit to the Special Issue?

(0) Thank | gggggggyyyyyyy

The reason is: you are not an insider.

(0) Thank | qjy6390

First submission, the status change was very fast, it took less than two weeks from submission to now. Five days ago, the status changed directly to "under review." I looked online and saw that there is a high probability of rejection, which makes me very sad.
I hope the editor can give me the final rejection reason so that I can know where I fell short. Graduation is also approaching, and I don't want to postpone it anymore. I am feeling anxious.

(0) Thank | 菠萝排骨

The manuscript review is very professional and meticulous. Generally speaking, if it is accepted, the journal will officially refine the language. The modifications regarding the format are very careful and serious, which can provide a great learning opportunity.

(2) Thank | 执笔画春秋

The reviewers are very professional and meticulous, they will point out everything from the overall structure of the article to even the smallest spelling errors. It is an excellent journal and worth recommending.

(0) Thank | Sugae

There were some formatting issues when I first submitted it for review, so I made some modifications and resubmitted it. After the first review, I forgot to execute the edits. After more than 40 days, I sent an email to remind them, and the next day I received the decision email. After two rounds of revisions, the editorial department had an American professor proofread the language. The first review was a bit slow, but the later stages were faster. The advantage of domestic journals is that we can directly communicate through Chinese emails. Moreover, this journal is from Zone 1 and is promoted by the Agricultural Sciences Academy, with an increasing impact factor.

(238) Thank | 遥花姬