This journal is very serious to check if the editor and the reviewers have conflict of interest with the authors. If it has, you have better not to review it, as this journal has put all the reviewers' name in the cover page.

(4) Thank | Jason Chen

I submitted a meta-analysis, which was under review in a week after submission, and minor revision was required in three weeks. Two weeks after the submission of revision, it was accepted. It is worth mentioning that the editor was very friendly, pointing out the grammatical and citation errors in the article directly, and directly giving suggestions on how to revise it. Just revise it as suggested.

(6) Thank | 西哥

I submitted a Meta-analysis article to this journal, which was soon under review. It was rejected after two days of review, saying that it had big problems with language and huge overlaps, the topic had been done. I decide to change the results of the article, change the title, update it and submit it to a journal with low impact factor. I am helpless.

(3) Thank | 阿胖门

The research topic submitted did not reach the hands of the editor, and it was rejected on Monday after being submitted on Friday. The reason for this decision is very disappointing: Issues related to compliance with research integrity policies, journal guidelines, or any other essential editorial criteria were identified in this manuscript that prevent further review or publication. This manuscript does not meet the standards established for the journal to be considered for publication, and it is in accordance with Frontiers policies. I am not sure where the problem lies, but at least the rejection was quick. Previously, I submitted to the second-tier journal BMC Cancer and it was sent for review. I do not know what this third-tier journal is thinking.

(0) Thank | mulberry27

Meta-analysis focusing on tumors:
Submitted on October 18, 2024;
Received review comments on December 22, 2024, with a total of 4 reviewers, 3 accepted with minor revisions, and 1 rejected;
The editor returned with modifications twice, and accepted on January 28, 2025;
Proofreading on February 7, 2025;
Published online on February 12, 2025.
The process from submission to acceptance took a total of over 3 months.

(0) Thank | 许鸽

How long did he review it in the end? He won't be looking for a new reviewer, will he?

(0) Thank | hao先生

One reviewer agreed to publish, while another rejected. Finally, in the editor module, the reasons for rejection were understood and modifications were made. It has been showing "review is ongoing" for two weeks without any changes. Does this mean rejection?

(0) Thank | 123

I hope he endorses too.

(0) Thank | 墟散云泽

Trashy magazines, submitted two articles, one has been waiting for almost four months without being assigned an editor, no response to emails, the other is even worse, after submitting for half a year, the comments from reviewers gradually came back, with one rejecting and two agreeing to publish after major revisions. I thought it would go smoothly, but after waiting for over a month for the associate editor to make a decision, I received a replacement for no reason. The new associate editor took over and another month passed, only to be ultimately rejected, with the reason being that the reviewers' comments were superficial and the article had no value. I am truly frustrated, he made hundreds of patients' cases seem worthless. I will never submit again, and the magazine that is dragging its feet on assigning editors is also withdrawing submissions.

(0) Thank | 西域鹏云

It has been a month since the editorial assignment was given, but editors have not been assigned yet. Despite reminders through emails, there has been no progress, which is causing concern. They are taking too long to take action.

(0) Thank | Adelaide Lawson

Please be patient. It seems that everything is moving slowly. Mine has also been two months.

(0) Thank | Adelaide Lawson

I also submitted my article in June, and I have only received one review so far. Is it really this slow?

(0) Thank | 仙灵佳惠

Submission success rate: 50.0
Experience sharing: In August, I submitted my work and received feedback from a total of 2 reviewers, both of whom provided some suggestions. However, it is worth noting that they did not recommend rejection. The system does not show whether the work has been finalized or rejected. Currently, it is undergoing the third round of review by another reviewer.

(1) Thank | Adelaide Lawson

Review speed: 3.0 Experience sharing: Just a note: I submitted my manuscript on June 20th, and it has been over three months now. In August, one of the reviewers has finished their review, but currently it still says "review is ongoing." Anyone had a similar experience? Let's chat.

(0) Thank | Adelaide Lawson

Brother, if the email is private, there is no need to pay attention to them.

(0) Thank | Mildred Harvey

I have been waiting for over three months and still have not been assigned an editor. I have sent emails but have not received any response.

(0) Thank | 西域鹏云

He is a scammer, I also received the email but did not pay, and also reported it.

(0) Thank | 黑山友梅

Will we be kicked, everyone?

(0) Thank | 应龙冰珍

It has been three months, Reviewer 1 completed their review two months ago, why is the review still ongoing? ?

(0) Thank | u

I am too.

(0) Thank | Gustave Coverdale

I have also encountered a similar article. It was a case where the patient reported had passed away. It is not known if it was due to this reason. I searched through their entire ethical section, but did not find any mention of this aspect. What was your article about?

(0) Thank | 萦思桑

Please wait patiently.

(0) Thank | 萦思桑

Review speed: 1.0 | Submission hit rate: 75.0 Emphasized research direction: Oncology Experience sharing: Mine is a review article, with a total of two reviewers invited, one of whom provided revision suggestions. After more than a month of revisions, it was accepted after 1 month and 2 weeks, with a total of 2 months from submission to publication.

(0) Thank | Adelaide Lawson

Why haven't I found a reviewer after a month? ?

(0) Thank | Gustave Coverdale

The two articles I received previously were sent to me via email at immunology.editorial.office@frontiersin.org and oncology.production.office@frontiersin.org. The scammer's email address is frontier.editorial.science@gmail.com.

(0) Thank | 萦思桑