Reviewing time after finding the reviewer: 2 months for the first review, 3 months for the second review.

(1) Thank | 脑浆豆腐花

The review time was quite long, and it was finally rejected and it was written that it could not be published. In short, it is not very responsible and time-consuming.

(9) Thank | 无心学术

I submitted an article on heat island effect and it has been accepted. The whole review process lasted more than 2 months. It was accepted after the revision was submitted. The efficiency was pretty high. The overall level of the journal is getting higher and higher, and it will be better in the future. It is worth recommending.

(8) Thank | yzw子非鱼

There are many big names on the editorial board of this journal. I have published another paper with this journal.  The editor-in-chief has recognized the quality of my paper and invited me to be a reviewer several times. Thank you very much for the opportunity!

(0) Thank | 齐德隆东墙

2025.02.02 submit as WE
2025.02.03 WE date update

(0) Thank | thermal19

2024.02.01 Submit as WE

(0) Thank | 想要发paper

Submitted to acceptance took almost 4 months, with one major revision. After the revision, it was accepted directly. Hope the journal will continue to improve!

(0) Thank | 杨

Submitted on February 26, 2024, with a first review period of three months, followed by a second review period of one month. Corrections will be accepted directly upon resubmission.

(0) Thank | 朱晓蕾

The recommendation is to have a review every three months, but it has been almost a month since the second review and there is still no news.

(0) Thank | 朱晓蕾

Rejected on the third day, very quickly. The template is the same as downstairs, but the content is lacking in creativity

(0) Thank | xxxt

How are you feeling?

(0) Thank | flashy

5.23 submit
5.24 with editor (handled by editor Zhuangbo Feng

(0) Thank | xxxt

May 21 Submitted to journal
May 23 With Editor

(0) Thank | 丹丹思密达

Title page should contain author information, delete the body text, the editor will probably ask you to resubmit

(0) Thank | 丹丹思密达

The Title Page should include author information, and the main text should be removed. You may need to resubmit as the editor will likely ask for it

(0) Thank | 丹丹思密达

Can I ask whether it is necessary to remove the authors' information when submitting a paper to this journal? I haven't noticed, and will it be rejected if not removed?

(0) Thank | yhqivi

Hello, does this journal require a plagiarism check?

(0) Thank | eian1

2024.01.30 submitted to journal
2024.01.31 With Editor (assigned executing editor)
2024.02.03 With Editor (executing editor completed review)
2024.02.19 Under Review (invited 7 reviewers, none accepted)
2024.03.07 Under Review (added 5 reviewers, 2 accepted)
2024.04.04 Under Review (2 accepted, 1 completed review)
2024.04.15 Required Reviews Completed (2 accepted, 2 completed review)
2024.04.18 Completed - Reject

(One reviewer requires major revisions, one rejected, blaming himself for being incompetent.)
(Plagiarism rate requirement around 10%

(0) Thank | LEOii-

Great journal, very efficient, accepted after major revisions

(0) Thank | 窝斯泥蝶

Hello, I was wondering about the specific difficulty of acceptance for this journal. Will manuscripts on regional coordinated development (at the provincial level) be rejected directly?

(0) Thank | 李初心

Do you know what is the required similarity index for this journal? Thank you! Also, can papers that have been rejected for high similarity index be resubmitted?

(0) Thank | luckmimi

Does anyone know what the plagiarism rate requirement is for this journal? Thank you! Also, can articles that are rejected due to plagiarism be resubmitted?

(0) Thank | luckmimi

Efficient work, the editors and reviewers were very responsive. Submitted in July, received major revisions in August, and accepted in October

(1) Thank | 越努力越幸运

Submitted the article on July 4th, under review since July 10th, the process is very fast, waiting for the results.

(0) Thank | 越努力越幸运

A very good journal.

(0) Thank | lele_accept