It has been submitted for nearly one month, the status is still with editor. I emailed and inquired, but received no reply. I don’t know what’s going on. Has it been so long without being sent for review? Are there too many manuscripts or for other reasons?

(4) Thank | donghongshu

The review speed is very fast. The three reviewers found are very professional. All three reviewers required revisions. A teacher from Peking University, I guess, gave sharp recommendations. All three reviewers accepted it after the revision. The editor also gave us a free round of polishing, which is really touching. A super good journal. The speed is also very fast. The first review took more than one month, and the second review took one month. It took five days for the polishing and then they sent the final version to the author for typeset proofreading.

(12) Thank | wangjiaoshou1990

It is now very difficult to get published here. The amount of submissions each year is very large, only a 10% acceptance rate. It seems that journals are more difficult.

(6) Thank | zju

4.6 send back to author (template issue)
4.7 resubmit

(0) Thank | ukiyo

3.30 PM

(0) Thank | ukiyo

The major revision I am referring to is a major revision, not the state you are in.

(0) Thank | 信号分析处理

Hello, blogger. My current status is Major revision and further review. Is this the normal state for a major revision? Shouldn't it only be Major revision? Is this the state of your major revisions?

(0) Thank | lunshi

Submission on October 29, 2024
First round of revisions on January 2, 2025
Revised manuscript returned on January 22, 2025
Accepted on February 10, 2025
Thank you to the journal for its fast review process and responsible editors. Best wishes for the continued success of the journal.

(0) Thank | 信号分析处理

Hello, do you have any results for your article now? I can't find any contact information to follow up on the submission, and I am unable to withdraw the article.

(0) Thank | Carrot_123

How is it going now?

(0) Thank | miacce

Submitted to journal 23.12.11
With Editor 23.12.19
Under Review 23.12.28
Under Review 24.1.10
Under Review 24.3.13
Required Reviews Completed 24.3.19
Reject and Resubmit 24.3.20

Submitted to journal 24.3.29
With Editor 24.3.29
Under Review 24.3.30
Under Review 24.4.26
Under Review 24.5.16
Under Review 24.7.31
Revise 24.8.12

Revision Submitted to Journal 24.8.24
With Editor 24.8.25
Under Review 24.8.25
Revise 24.9.9

Revision Submitted to Journal 24.9.18
With Editor 24.9.18
Accept 24.9.18

(0) Thank | GKALLIN

The application was submitted on April 1, 2024, and the UR process started in May, continuing until now. The date has now changed to July 17th, it's been almost five months already, but I don't dare to rush. Why does it feel like my process is much slower than everyone else's? What's going on here? Can I push for it?

(0) Thank | shenyi

Why do non-OA also need to charge money?

(0) Thank | ll8657

Hello, could you please provide the submission website for this journal?

(0) Thank | 五百大洋

Hello, could you please provide me with the submission website for this journal?

(0) Thank | 五百大洋

I would like to ask, is it normal that more than 10 days have passed and it is still "Submitted to Journal"?

(0) Thank | 111

It has been over ten days and the status is still "Submitted to Journal." Is this normal?

(0) Thank | 111

Submitted, 15 May, 2024
Desk Reject, 18 May, 2024

(0) Thank | Talusul

submitted, 15 May, 2024

(0) Thank | Talusul

1. October 31, 2023: Submitted to Journal
2. December 11, 2023: Revise and resubmit
3. December 29, 2023: Resubmit
4. January 2, 2024: Under Review
5. January 29, 2024: RRC
6. January 30, 2024: Major Revision
7. February 24, 2024: Revision Submitted to Journal
8. April 16, 2024: AC

(0) Thank | Apoiuty

It has been over a month since the second revision was submitted for review. Previously, feedback was provided within a month

(0) Thank | Apoiuty

Submitted for the third time to this journal, here is an overview of the process:
1. Submitted at the end of July, received first-round feedback in early September which was a rejection and resubmit;
2. Completed revisions by the end of September, received nine relatively friendly comments in the second round of review by the end of October, most of which were questions on the mechanisms that the reviewers did not understand;
3. Finished revisions in early November, received feedback in less than a week and thought it was accepted, but then was asked to address three more issues-_-!!!;
4. Due to year-end busyness, feedback was delayed until early December, after waiting for three days, it was finally accepted!
In summary, this journal has a decent speed and quality. Submissions are anonymous, reviewers are very meticulous and thorough, taking about a month for each round of revisions

(0) Thank | ChaoJ

My brother had a similar situation. After the review process, one reviewer asked for major revisions while the other asked for minor revisions. The editor rejected it and suggested submitting to another journal. Can we still resubmit to this journal after making the necessary changes?

(0) Thank | kubikeyanren

I submitted three times. The first submission was rejected after exactly two months, and the editor suggested submitting to another journal. I made significant revisions based on the reviewer's feedback. The second submission was rejected approximately 15 days later, with the editor suggesting that I make further modifications before attempting to submit to the same journal again. I made significant revisions for the second time and also wrote a response letter (initially, I didn't upload it, but the editor returned it and requested that I include the response letter. In other words, for this second rejection, a response letter was required). After my third submission, I received minor revisions after 45 days. I completed the revisions within a week, and the journal accepted it in less than a week. The speed of this journal is truly impressive.

(0) Thank | lanbai

Please provide a template or link for this journal. Thank you all.

(0) Thank | SCI炮灰选手